I Really Want to Love the Mandoline...

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread centers around participants' experiences and challenges with the mandoline, particularly in relation to slicing tomatoes and other vegetables. Several users share their personal opinions on the product's usability and effectiveness, while others discuss alternative tools and techniques.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant, identifying as a consultant, expresses difficulty in using the mandoline for tomatoes, noting that they often end up mushy.
  • Another participant mentions that tomatoes should not be overripe and suggests refrigerating them for better slicing.
  • Several users recommend using roma tomatoes and specific blades, such as the v-blade, for better results.
  • One participant shares their preference for the Green Tomato Knife over the mandoline for slicing tomatoes.
  • Another participant expresses dissatisfaction with the mandoline, preferring to showcase other tools like the tomato knife and cheese grater instead.
  • Some participants mention that they only use the mandoline at shows and not in their personal cooking, citing its impracticality.
  • One participant notes that practice with potatoes can help improve skills with the mandoline.
  • Several users comment on the finicky nature of the mandoline, with some stating that food often gets stuck in the blades.
  • One participant mentions a preference for the Ultimate Slice and Grate, expressing disappointment with the mandoline's design and functionality.
  • Another participant shares that they love using the mandoline for French Onion Soup, highlighting its usefulness in certain recipes.
  • Some participants discuss the importance of using fresh produce for optimal results with the mandoline.
  • One participant expresses concern about the quality of the mandoline compared to other brands.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ significantly regarding the effectiveness and usability of the mandoline. While some participants appreciate its potential for specific tasks, many express frustration and dissatisfaction with its performance, particularly for slicing tomatoes.

Contextual Notes

Participants share a range of personal experiences and preferences related to the mandoline and other kitchen tools, reflecting a variety of cooking styles and practices within the consultant community.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to Pampered Chef consultants looking for insights into the mandoline's usability and alternative tools for food preparation.

I used it a lot when i first got my kit...haven't used it for a while until tonight. I used it to cut onions to make tobacco onions! It worked great!! So quick to slice them! I do like it a lot. Definitely not for limes!
 
I have the UM, but it sits in my hutch unused because I have the US&G. I like the US&G. I use it to slice onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, and to grate cheese...I hate the cheese grater for soft cheese. I use the cheese grater for chocolate, nuts, parm. cheese and carrots.
 
urbnk8 said:
I used it a lot when i first got my kit...haven't used it for a while until tonight. I used it to cut onions to make tobacco onions! It worked great!! So quick to slice them! I do like it a lot. Definitely not for limes!

What are these tobacco onions?:)
 
What are these tobacco onions?

lol I was scared to ask. I was hoping she meant Tabasco. :p
 
I'm a firm believer that the Mandolin takes some gettin' used to. My husband played with mine forever after I signed up because I didn't like it much...He found THE best ways to grate cheese and slice anything!!! He showed off his skills at our cluster meeting! :D His advice: use it until its comfortable, and try it using with the handle facing you and (especially with cheese) push down instead of the normal sideways way. If that makes any sense at all lol!
 
I LOVE my UM!! I use it all the time for different things. But my sister hates her's. I keep trying to tell her that we should get together and have a class about it!
 
I had the hardest time getting the UM to work for me the first time I tried it. I ended up getting my husband in the kitchen and it worked for him the first time he tried it! ROFL.....I told him maybe HE should be selling PC!

Anywhoo....I practiced and practiced with limes and tomatoes and I thought I had it until my first show. I was doing the cran raspberry fizz, and was going to show them how to slice the limes with the UM. I could not get those limes to slice correctly! I don't want to blame the UM entirely, because it probably didn't help that I was nervous seeing as how it was my first show, but I have realized that it is a little touchy sometimes. Then as soon as I got home I got out a lime to try it again, and it worked prefectly!! ARGH! :)

I have never used the US&G, but I have had at least 2 customers who have the UM and the US&G and they like the US&G best. They say the US&G slices thicker than the UM does, and it isn't so difficult to use. I showed one hostess how to adjust the slicing width on her UM, but she still said it wasn't as thick of slices as her US&G.
 
  • Thread starter
  • #39
When you grate cheese at a show what do you use if people aren't using the mandoline?
 
I don't use the mandoline to grate cheese, I use the deluxe cheese grater.
 
pamperedmomto3 said:
When you grate cheese at a show what do you use if people aren't using the mandoline?
Personally, I never grate soft cheeses at a show. I either grate them when I am prepping for the show - or I just tell my host to get pre-grated cheese. I do use the mandoline if I need to grate cheese though - so much easier than the deluxe cheese grater....now that is one thing from PC I can do without...in fact, after my third one broke, I never replaced it - don't even have one anymore, and never miss it!

I use my Microplane grater to grate hard cheeses. I LOVE :love: the Microplane Grater!
 
ChefBeckyD said:
I use my Microplane grater to grate hard cheeses. I LOVE :love: the Microplane Grater!


I second that !!!

:chef:
 
Loved reading this thread...the Mandoline is why I booked my first PC party and now I'm a consultant. So ironic!

Here's my .02: the mandoline makes quick work of very firm veggies and fruits, even plum tomatoes. I love it for potatoes - slice up some white and sweet, toss with olive oil, a little salt and whatever spices, and bake at 425 until you have almost guilt-free potato chips!

I have to admit, though, that I use the cheese grater, tomato knife, and forged cutlery more often.....

To each her own!
 
I've tried using it a couple times and have trouble with it. I don't like that I can't put a whole cuke or carrot on it and slice away. I find the guard to be very hard to use.

I'll have to practice more!
 
I'm in the not-a-big-fan of the UM club, too. I stopped taking it to shows, too, because I never had much luck (especially with cheese, even if I froze it before I tried to grate it). If a hosts asks me about it, I'll bring it. I have even let a couple of hosts keep it for a day or two to play with it. One host, an older lady, absolutely loved it and ordered it as one of her half-price items. The younger gal was too intimidated by it. Maybe it's an "experience" thing. More experienced cooks are more comfortable with it. My host who ordered it said she makes homemade scalloped potatoes frequently and she was very excited about it. I included the care & use guide and the tip sheet that's available on CC. She had no problems. One of these days when I have some free time (anyone have any?! lol) I'll buy some cheap fruit and practice. Good luck with it!
 
I'm on anti-coagulants and am so happy they redesigned the mandoline! (I'm not allowed to bleed.) It is so safe now. I show it at almost every show.
 
https://www.pamperedchef.com/repsonly/product_information/product_demo_video.jsp

About midway down the page...watch the demo videos about the UM. One thing I have changed since watching these...how I hold onto the food plunger. Watch how they are NOT pushing down on the plunger...their fingers are UNDER the plunger till it gets down closer to the end of the food. I don't push down on it at all till then. I let gravity pull the food down with each pass. Then, even when I move my hand to be on TOP of the plunger, I still do not apply too much pressure. If you push too hard, the food gets stuck in the blade terribly.

It certainly takes some practice, and I still only like doing potatoes and onions...or using the grater blade for cheese. I am another consultant who REALLY dislikes the deluxe cheese grater. I LOVE our microplane grater though!!
 
RaggedyAunt said:
I'm in the not-a-big-fan of the UM club, too. I stopped taking it to shows, too, because I never had much luck (especially with cheese, even if I froze it before I tried to grate it). If a hosts asks me about it, I'll bring it. I have even let a couple of hosts keep it for a day or two to play with it. One host, an older lady, absolutely loved it and ordered it as one of her half-price items. The younger gal was too intimidated by it. Maybe it's an "experience" thing. More experienced cooks are more comfortable with it. My host who ordered it said she makes homemade scalloped potatoes frequently and she was very excited about it. I included the care & use guide and the tip sheet that's available on CC. She had no problems. One of these days when I have some free time (anyone have any?! lol) I'll buy some cheap fruit and practice. Good luck with it!


Meijers has lemons and limes $2 a bag right now!:)
 
I have always used a mandoline--use to use another brand and ended up cutting the tip of my finger off. Had to go to the husband hours before I was hosting a party--though still had it with a slithly smaller finger. My husband is glad for PC's because of it doesn't work without the guard. The only thing I wish PC had on theirs is the julienne blade.
Andrea

I tell my finger story everytime I use the mandoline to try to sell it!
 
RaggedyAunt said:
I'm in the not-a-big-fan of the UM club, too. I stopped taking it to shows, too, because I never had much luck (especially with cheese, even if I froze it before I tried to grate it). If a hosts asks me about it, I'll bring it. I have even let a couple of hosts keep it for a day or two to play with it. One host, an older lady, absolutely loved it and ordered it as one of her half-price items. The younger gal was too intimidated by it. Maybe it's an "experience" thing. More experienced cooks are more comfortable with it. My host who ordered it said she makes homemade scalloped potatoes frequently and she was very excited about it. I included the care & use guide and the tip sheet that's available on CC. She had no problems. One of these days when I have some free time (anyone have any?! lol) I'll buy some cheap fruit and practice. Good luck with it!

My boyfriend is a chef & when I was having no luck what so ever he got it from me & started slicing like it was no big deal. So I agree with the "experience" might help.
 
Every time I try it, my slices of veggies are paper thin. I have adjusted the blade back and forth, and there's not much difference. Is there a way to make them thicker? I can practically see through my slices. If they were thicker I'd use it a lot more.
 
I made the BIG mistake of trying to cut lemons with it AT A SHOW w/o practicing at home and just got embarassed. Thank you for all who posted that practice makes perfect. I will do that and give it another chance and not throw it against the wall anymore...
 
Tanoi said:
Every time I try it, my slices of veggies are paper thin. I have adjusted the blade back and forth, and there's not much difference. Is there a way to make them thicker? I can practically see through my slices. If they were thicker I'd use it a lot more.
The V-shaped blade cuts thicker than the adjustable blade.
 
I don't think it's an experience thing, I never cooked much before PC and owned both the USG and UM. I like the UM better because it's safer but it's always in my car so I will pull out the USG once in a while, just use it very carefully. It can take some time to get used to it. Watch the video and try it again yourself.
 
Then as soon as I got home I got out a lime to try it again, and it worked prefectly!! ARGH!

This has happened to me at 3 shows. Limes & tomatoes slice perfectly for me at home, every time. So, I know how to use the UM. It just betrays me at shows.

Now, I don't use the UM at a show unless it's a potato or apple.
 

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
raebates
  • emiscookin
  • Products and Tips
Replies
14
Views
4K
chefheidi2003
  • tinat51796
  • Products and Tips
Replies
11
Views
4K
chefann
  • JillianAnthony
  • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
1K
jbachen
  • kcjodih
  • Products and Tips
Replies
12
Views
2K
raebates
  • RMDave
  • Products and Tips
2
Replies
55
Views
20K
iteachncook
  • clshirk
  • Products and Tips
2
Replies
31
Views
10K
jenapc
Replies
7
Views
3K
rlombas
  • Jolie_Paradoxe
  • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
2K
Jolie_Paradoxe
  • PCwithStay-C
  • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
2K
Chef Kearns
Back
Top