Grill vs Griddle: What's Best for French Toast?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores the preferences and experiences of participants regarding the use of grill pans versus square griddles for making French toast and other dishes. Participants share their thoughts on the practicality and versatility of each pan type.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses uncertainty about whether French toast can be made in a grill pan and wishes for higher walls in the griddle.
  • Another participant finds the square griddle awkward to store due to its size and handles but still prefers it.
  • A participant mentions using both pans, noting that while they use the griddle for French toast, the grill pan is favored during colder months for cooking various meats.
  • One participant shares that their husband initially doubted the need for a grill pan but now uses it frequently for cooking, including hamburgers.
  • Another participant suggests that making French toast in the grill pan is feasible and expresses a strong preference for the grill pan, highlighting its versatility for grilling vegetables and meats.
  • One participant believes the grill pan is beneficial for business, as it appeals to customers looking for versatile cooking options.
  • A participant expresses love for the grill pan, mentioning its ease of cleaning compared to other appliances and its ability to keep meat moist.
  • Another participant agrees on the grill pan's effectiveness, noting its use for various meats and its convenience over outdoor grilling.
  • One participant shares their enthusiasm for the grill pan, stating it has made their cooking experience more enjoyable and efficient.
  • Another participant reiterates that the grill pan is popular among customers at shows, leading to full-price purchases.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally express a preference for the grill pan, with several noting its versatility and effectiveness. However, there are differing opinions on the practicality of the square griddle, with some participants favoring it for specific uses like making pancakes and French toast.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences with both pans, focusing on their cooking preferences and the impact on their culinary practices.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants considering which pan to recommend or purchase for their cooking needs may find the shared experiences and opinions helpful.

B
basketmom2
Messages
31
Hi, trying to decide which pan I should get. The grill or square griddle. Can you make french toast in the grill pan? I wish the walls were higher in the griddle.

Thanks for your opinoin.
 
The griddle is big...with the handles, it is kind of awekward to store... JMO... I would like the square griddle, as I do not have that one yet.
 
I have both the grill pan and square griddle. We do use the griddle pan for french toast. We do use our grill pan more especially now that it's cold outside. I've cooked steaks, pork chops, and boneless chicken breast and they all come out so juicy it's unbelievable. I would also recommend getting the grill press. Plus you can't forget the panini's.
 
my husband swore we didn't need the grill pan. Well, I got it because of the grill press and now he uses it ALL the time! In fact, I was at a vendor showcase last night and its sitting on the stove because he made hamburgers last night. He is too funny!:)
 
I would imagine that making french toast in the grill pan is not out of the question. I have both pans and absolutely would suggest the grill pan to anyone! Grill veggies, paninis, meat......maybe I'll have to try french toast! It's definitely worth getting...I have the grill press as well and love that!
 
I think the grill pan is better for your business. More people are looking for something like that, plus you can do panini shows.
 
I LOVE the grill pan. I threw out my George Foreman because I was tired of trying to clean it. You can do anything in it ... plus it really keeps the meat moist. The grill press is an awesome tool with the grill pan. I plan on using it in January for my shows since Cookware will be on special.
 
I agree - the grill pan is awesome - makes chicken breasts so incredibly moist - my family loves it. I've also used it for fish as well. Glad I have it - much easier than cleaning your outdoor grill as well!! I also have the square griddle which is great for making pancakes and french toast, or grilled cheese -we like to eat breakfast for dinner a lot.

Gina
 
I LOVE my grill pans. My steaks are very moist in it!! I cook hamburgers and chicken too. I went panini crzy when I first got it. Any sandwich that would be done h ot instantly became a panini!
 
cmdtrgd said:
I think the grill pan is better for your business. More people are looking for something like that, plus you can do panini shows.
Click to expand...

I agree! I've had several people buy the grill pan full price at a show b/c they liked it so much!
 

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the main difference between a grill and a griddle for cooking French toast?

The main difference lies in their cooking surfaces. A grill has raised ridges that create grill marks and allow grease to drain away, while a griddle has a flat, smooth surface that provides even heat distribution. For French toast, a griddle is often preferred for its ability to cook the bread evenly without the risk of it falling through the grates.

2. Can I use a grill to make French toast?

Yes, you can use a grill to make French toast, but it may require more attention to prevent the bread from sticking or falling apart. Using a grill can add a unique smoky flavor, but it may not achieve the same even cooking as a griddle.

3. Which option is better for cooking multiple slices of French toast at once?

A griddle is generally better for cooking multiple slices of French toast at once due to its larger, flat surface area. This allows you to fit several slices side by side, making it more efficient for serving larger groups.

4. How does cooking time differ between a grill and a griddle for French toast?

Cooking time can vary slightly between the two. A griddle typically cooks French toast more evenly and may require less time overall, while a grill may take longer due to the need to manage heat and prevent burning on the grill marks.

5. What are the advantages of using a griddle for French toast?

The advantages of using a griddle for French toast include even heat distribution, the ability to cook multiple slices at once, and a non-stick surface that makes flipping and serving easier. Additionally, griddles often have higher sides, which can help contain any batter that might spill over during cooking.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Garlic Toast In Less Than a Minute with a Grill Pan!
  • PampChefJoy
    • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
2K
bethsbiz
Which Is a Better Investment: Grill Pan or Knife Block?
  • lauriedip
    • Products and Tips
Replies
22
Views
3K
raebates
Maximize Your POR Points: Redeem for Cookware and More!
  • crystalscookingnow
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
rlombas
  • Poll Poll
Stainless Cookware Vs. Executive Cookware
  • jessicafawn
    • Products and Tips
Replies
22
Views
11K
KellyTheChef
Grill Pan vs 12 Skillet: Choosing the Best Pan for Cooking Shows and Bookings
  • ldynred7
    • Pampered Chef Bookings
Replies
7
Views
2K
BlueMoon
What are Good Side Dishes for a Breakfast for Dinner Themed Party?
  • littlemaisyPC
    • Pampered Chef Shows
Replies
6
Views
2K
Teresa Lynn
Can anyone help with a replacement handle for a Gen II Square Griddle?
  • RachelNguyen
    • Buy and Sell Items
Replies
2
Views
2K
janetupnorth
Expert Tips for Selling Cookware: Boost Your Sales with These Proven Strategies
  • marystell1
    • Pampered Chef Sales
Replies
4
Views
3K
marystell1
Best Sample Package for Newbies?
  • slapsappyhappy
    • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
2K
BethCooks4U
Executive Vs. Stainless: Choosing the Best Cookware for Your Kitchen
  • hperschnick
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
rlombas
Back
Top