Will My Amish Friendship Bread Turn Out OK With Chocolate Pudding Mix?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores the experiences and opinions of participants regarding the use of chocolate pudding mix in Amish Friendship Bread, as well as sharing personal anecdotes related to the bread-making process.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based

Main Points Raised

  • One participant, identifying as a consultant, expressed uncertainty about the outcome of using chocolate pudding mix instead of vanilla in Amish Friendship Bread.
  • Another participant mentioned having encountered various recipes that suggest different variations of the bread.
  • Several users noted that the batter is basic and can accommodate different ingredients, such as raisins and nuts, as well as different pudding flavors.
  • One participant shared a positive experience with the bread, noting that it was well-received by their family.
  • Another participant mentioned having used chocolate pudding in the past and offered to share the starter recipe.
  • Some participants discussed the process of making Amish Friendship Bread, describing it as a communal activity involving sharing starters with friends.
  • One participant reported that their bread turned out delicious, despite having an unusual greenish color, and expressed interest in trying vanilla pudding next time.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ regarding the use of chocolate pudding mix, with some participants expressing confidence in its suitability while others share personal experiences that suggest varying outcomes.

Contextual Notes

The discussion reflects a mix of personal experiences and informal exchanges about baking practices and preferences within the context of Amish Friendship Bread.

Who May Find This Useful

Participants in the consultant community interested in baking variations and personal anecdotes related to Amish Friendship Bread may find this thread engaging.

KellyTheChef
KellyTheChef
Gold Member
Messages
7,533
I had an Amish Friendship starter...and it was due to make the bread today. I didn't have the vanilla pudding mix it called for, so I used chocolate. They are in the oven right now...is this gonna turn out ok?

 
It should. I ran across several recipes a while ago that had different variations of the bread.
 
  • Thread starter
  • #3
Cool. That's what I figured...it's a pretty basic batter, so I would think you could add stuff (raisins, nuts, etc.) and change up the pudding flavor to vary it.

I topped one with caramel sprinkles and the other with cinnamon....I'll let you know how they turn out!

 
I got a starter once and DH looked at it with disgust every day. Until I baked the bread! It was the best thing he ever tasted. He asked me a while back to see if I could get another starter but then changed his mind. I should probably email my friend, it sounds good to me too.
 
I've used chocolate before...wadesgirl - do you need the starter recipe?
 
ok - ladies - Enlighten the LI girl - what is amish starter??
 
PamperedDor said:
ok - ladies - Enlighten the LI girl - what is amish starter??
Click to expand...

Amish Friendship Bread

Someone gives you a bag (they hand them out to friends) with a sheet and you follow the sheets...

You mash for a few days, then add a few ingredients then mash again and let sit, then on the appointed day you bake it, and also create bags to pass on...

It is great bread...


I have to go clean my vehicle right now but when I come back in an hour or so, I'll dig up the recipe and post it.
 
Oy Vey - sounds like work to me!!! LOL -

Janet clean the car and let me know the recipe - not sure if I will do the whole giving to my friend thing but.....

(You guys will understand when you meet me - live on LI but should be in 90210!! LOL)
 
PamperedDor said:
Oy Vey - sounds like work to me!!! LOL -

Janet clean the car and let me know the recipe - not sure if I will do the whole giving to my friend thing but.....

(You guys will understand when you meet me - live on LI but should be in 90210!! LOL)
Click to expand...

Too funny! Try being a city girl transformed to redneck county. Wait 'til you meet me - I've thrown fashion and much technology out the door to be practical and raise a family. I actually wear makeup at conference when everyday I usually don't!

Don't worry, you can do the bread without passing on, you can some for yourself or just waste a few ingredients.

OK, be back later...(...and it is a van so it might take me a little bit! It hasn't been cleaned all winter! :yuck: )
 
janetupnorth said:
Too funny! Try being a city girl transformed to redneck county. Wait 'til you meet me - I've thrown fashion and much technology out the door to be practical and raise a family. I actually wear makeup at conference when everyday I usually don't!
Don't worry, you can do the bread without passing on, you can some for yourself or just waste a few ingredients.

OK, be back later...(...and it is a van so it might take me a little bit! It hasn't been cleaned all winter! :yuck: )
Click to expand...


LOL!!! And although I live out in Eastern LI - away from the "city" as we call lit - Lets just say - I have 3 fashion divas as daughters and OMG - I would like never leave the house with out makeup - LOL - I awake at 5:45 daily to make sure the kids are up and ready for school and that I LOOK nice to take them to the bus stop - LOL -

Nails are done every 10 days and never go a week without a pedi in the summer - LOL - Yes my husband is a saint!!! I am a really down to earth person - just very self conscious!! LOL:o
 
It is yummy bread!! I have used Chocolate before as well as put chocolate chips in it!
 
StacieB said:
It is yummy bread!! I have used Chocolate before as well as put chocolate chips in it!
Click to expand...


I posted the recipe in "Recipe Tips".
 
  • Thread starter
  • #13
OK...so it is baked and most of the first loaf is GONE!! Very yummy!

But- it has a greenish color to it. The top 1/2 inch of the loaf looks brownish-red like a chocolate muffin would, but the rest of the loaf looks like I added some dark green food coloring to it! (I used two small boxes of instant pudding mix...one Chocolate and one Chocolate Fudge) No one here seems to mind the color, but it's very odd!

Oh...and the one with the caramel sprinkles is better, IMHO.

I think next time I will try the vanilla pudding and see what color it turns out! LOL
 
PamperedDor said:
LOL!!! And although I live out in Eastern LI - away from the "city" as we call lit - Lets just say - I have 3 fashion divas as daughters and OMG - I would like never leave the house with out makeup - LOL - I awake at 5:45 daily to make sure the kids are up and ready for school and that I LOOK nice to take them to the bus stop - LOL -

Nails are done every 10 days and never go a week without a pedi in the summer - LOL - Yes my husband is a saint!!! I am a really down to earth person - just very self conscious!! LOL:o
Click to expand...

I like you already - LOL
 
dannyzmom said:
I like you already - LOL
Click to expand...

I was thinking when she posted that you two would definitely hit it off great! :thumbup:
 

Frequently Asked Questions

Will my Amish Friendship Bread turn out okay with chocolate pudding mix?

Yes, using chocolate pudding mix in your Amish Friendship Bread can add a rich chocolate flavor and moist texture. Many bakers enjoy experimenting with different pudding flavors to create unique variations of this classic recipe.

How does chocolate pudding mix affect the texture of the bread?

Chocolate pudding mix can enhance the moisture and softness of the bread. The added ingredients in the pudding mix contribute to a tender crumb, making your bread more enjoyable to eat.

Can I use instant chocolate pudding mix instead of cooked pudding mix?

Yes, you can use instant chocolate pudding mix in your Amish Friendship Bread recipe. Instant pudding is designed to be mixed directly into batters without cooking, making it a convenient option for this type of bread.

Will the flavor of the chocolate pudding overpower the bread?

The flavor of the chocolate pudding should complement the other ingredients rather than overpower them. However, if you prefer a milder chocolate taste, you can reduce the amount of pudding mix used or balance it with other flavors, such as vanilla or nuts.

What other variations can I try with chocolate pudding mix in my Amish Friendship Bread?

You can add ingredients like chocolate chips, nuts, or even spices like cinnamon to enhance the flavor profile. Additionally, consider pairing the chocolate pudding mix with other flavors, such as almond or coconut, for a unique twist on the traditional recipe.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Baking Amish Friendship Bread: How Full Should the Tube Be?
  • gothim0802
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
wadesgirl
How can I turn candy canes into a delicious trifle?
  • janezapchef
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
12
Views
6K
scottcooks
Indulge in Our Sinful Chocolate Ribbon Bread Pudding Recipe for Two
  • Chefstover2
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
11
Views
3K
Chefstover2
Trying Cobbler and Pudding Cakes in the Deep Covered Baker
  • lovenpc
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
23
Views
4K
dkgriff
Amish Cinnamon Friendship Bread Starter
  • janetupnorth
    • Recipes and Tips
2 3
Replies
81
Views
16K
lmradlein
Chocolate Cake Test-Run: What's Next?
  • Jenni
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
29
Views
3K
Fluffy215
Why did my pumpkin trifle turn into a disaster?
  • Intrepid_Chef
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
8
Views
3K
Michelle817
Molten Chocolate Skillet Brownie
  • stefani2
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
4
Views
2K
Staci
Find the Perfect Chocolate Pizza Recipe: Chocolate Decadence
  • mom2leelee
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
mom2leelee
My New Addiction- Hot Chocolate With Sprinkles
  • Yakmama
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
5
Views
1K
chefSherry
Back
Top