Which Skillet Size to Choose: 10 or 12?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores the preferences and experiences of participants regarding the choice between a 10-inch and a 12-inch skillet. Participants share their thoughts on the practicality, usage, and cleaning of both sizes.

Discussion Character

  • Opinion-based
  • Anecdotal

Main Points Raised

  • One participant, identifying as a consultant, mentions that the 10-inch skillet is easier to wash and is suitable for smaller meals, especially for a family of four.
  • Another participant shares their experience using the 12-inch skillet frequently, noting its versatility for larger meals and even for making skillet cakes.
  • Several users express a strong preference for the 12-inch skillet, citing its greater capacity and usefulness for various cooking tasks.
  • One participant highlights that while the 10-inch skillet is useful, they could manage without it if they had the 12-inch skillet.
  • Another participant mentions that the 12-inch skillet is their favorite piece and is often used during shows.
  • One participant discusses the ease of cleaning the 12-inch skillet, stating that they rarely need to soak it and find it manageable to wash.
  • Another participant notes that the 12-inch skillet has helped with meal prep and budgeting by allowing for leftovers.
  • Some participants inquire about the backorder status of the 12-inch skillet and express interest in when it will be available for shipping.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

General agreement exists among participants that the 12-inch skillet is preferred for its larger capacity and versatility, although some participants still find value in the 10-inch skillet for smaller meals.

Contextual Notes

Participants discuss their personal experiences with both skillet sizes, considering factors like family size, meal preparation needs, and cleaning preferences.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants considering which skillet size to purchase may find the shared experiences and preferences helpful in making their decision.

J
jesusluvsu2005
Messages
386
If you had to pick and could only get one, which would you choose? I think I can still get the 10" for $37 or something like that on the sample orders (I think I can order it within my first 30 days or something like that). Granted the 12" would be 40% off. I know the 12" is backordered right now. Do they know when it will be off backorder? I'd like the 12" to have the opportunity to do power cooking but the 10" is probably a bit easier to wash since they are handwash only. For those of you that have these skillets which would you choose? Thanks!
God bless,
Amanda
 
I use the 10 in more, but the 12 in comes in handy when I'm making alot..I think it depends on your family size (there's me and dh and 2 younger kids)..and things are perfect in that 10 in.
So for me it would be that and I COULD NOT live w/o it! I feel the 12 in I could, as long as I had the stir fry! LOL
 
12" all the way! I use mine all the time, and there's only 2 of us at home. You can do skillet cakes in the 12", too. (The Pina Colada Upside Down cake in the SBRC is great.)
 
12"! It really does come in more use than my 10". I only use the 10" (it's just DH and I) when I'm too lazy to clean the 12".
 
12" for shows and cakes! But I do use my 10" alot at home!
 
I'd get the 12"... I want the 12"... whatever you can do in the 10" you can do in the 12" plus more....
 
12" definetly!!!!!
 
It's like I tell my customers who consider the Medium Round Stone - You can do less on the big one, but you can't necessarily do more on the smaller one. :)(Why does every post I write today sound dirty? :rolleyes: )
 
I say 12" inch too. And remember, the one on the sample order is only the 10" saute pan, not the skillet.
 
  • Thread starter
  • #10
Hmmm, it seems the majority vote is for the 12". And I know it's really the size I need at home. There's 5 of us. But I just hate the thought of handwashing that big of a pan. Do any of y'all have difficulty with it in the sink? Also, anyone know when they'll be avaiable to ship? Thanks again!
God bless,
Amanda
 
12 inch the whole way - Its my favorite piece and at my show its my try me piece!! LOVE LOVE LOVE IT!!!
 
I used the 12 inch professional so much that I didn't think it could be improved upon... until I used the executive at my director's house and borrowed it for a show and then I had to have that one too! So now I have two and also the 10 inch executive saute pan, but I use the 12 inch for pancakes a lot. Plus, the new executive is so heavy! I take it to power cooking shows and just brag about it! It is fun to see people pick it up and they usually can't do so with one hand! Now, on those shows, I don't take a lot of other heavy stuff. I love the ten inch for fritattas and other egg dishes. They are both great pans. Its like choosing a favorite ice cream flavor... so many good things about both! I guess it depends on what you need it for... But, hands down they are both professional grade!

As far as when they will be available... it would be worth waiting for the 12 inch. In my humble opinion.
 
Last edited:
jesusluvsu2005 said:
Do any of y'all have difficulty with it in the sink?
Click to expand...
I barely need to put mine in the sink, and I've got the Professional one, which isn't as nice as the Exec. Seriously - I rinse it, wipe it out with a soapy sponge, rinse again, and it's clean! Not fitting into the sink is not going to be a problem.
 
Chef Stephanie Petersen said:
I used the 12 inch professional so much that I didn't think it could be improved upon... until I used the executive at my director's house and borrowed it for a show and then I had to have that one too! So now I have two and also the 10 inch executive saute pan, but I use the 12 inch for pancakes a lot. Plus, the new executive is so heavy! I take it to power cooking shows and just brag about it! It is fun to see people pick it up and they usually can't do so with one hand! Now, on those shows, I don't take a lot of other heavy stuff. I love the ten inch for fritattas and other egg dishes. They are both great pans. Its like choosing a favorite ice cream flavor... so many good things about both! I guess it depends on what you need it for... But, hands down they are both professional grade!

As far as when they will be available... it would be worth waiting for the 12 inch. In my humble opinion.
Click to expand...


Hee Hee - now, just borrow your directors double burner griddle for pancakes one time....and you'll suddenly have a need for that one too!:D :p
 
I love my 12" Executive Skillet as well! It's just me, DH and two toddlers that don't eat much, but I love that I can make enough for DH to take leftovers for lunch the next day. It has actually really helped out our budget a lot as he is not eating out as much.
 
urbnk8 said:
I say 12" inch too. And remember, the one on the sample order is only the 10" saute pan, not the skillet.
Click to expand...
Good point!

I have a sink with out a sprayer and I wash it just fine. When I hand wash I usually don't fill the sink up, just run some hot water, use soap and the kitchen brush. The kitchen brush is a must with the cookware! Helps to clean it beautifully.
 
I just got my 12" last week (hosted my own show) and I've only used it once, but am in love!!! Like cheffann and wadesgirl said, it's really easy to just run some hot water and use a soapy scrub brush to clean it.

As far as it being on BO, mine came last week with the rest of my show...
 
By the way it is bigger than I thought but that baby holds alot of stuff! I love it!
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between a 10-inch and a 12-inch skillet?

The main differences between a 10-inch and a 12-inch skillet are their size and cooking capacity. A 10-inch skillet is ideal for smaller meals or side dishes, while a 12-inch skillet offers more surface area, making it suitable for larger meals or when cooking for a family. The 12-inch skillet can also accommodate more ingredients, which is beneficial for stir-frying or searing.

Which skillet size is better for cooking for a family?

The 12-inch skillet is generally better for cooking for a family. Its larger surface area allows you to prepare more food at once, making it easier to cook meals that serve multiple people. If you frequently entertain or have a larger household, the 12-inch skillet will likely be more practical.

Can I use a 10-inch skillet for larger recipes?

You can use a 10-inch skillet for larger recipes, but it may require cooking in batches. This can be less efficient and may lead to uneven cooking if you're not careful. If you often cook larger meals, a 12-inch skillet would be a more suitable choice.

Is there a significant weight difference between the two skillet sizes?

Yes, there is typically a weight difference between the two skillet sizes. A 12-inch skillet is generally heavier due to its larger size and material used. This can affect how easy it is to handle, especially when full of food. If you prefer a lighter skillet, the 10-inch option may be more comfortable for you.

Which skillet size is more versatile for different cooking techniques?

The 12-inch skillet is often considered more versatile for different cooking techniques. Its larger size allows for a variety of cooking methods, including sautéing, frying, and even baking. While a 10-inch skillet can handle many techniques, the added space of a 12-inch skillet provides more flexibility for various recipes.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Which 12" Skillet is Best: Stainless or Non-Stick?
  • Dotty
    • Products and Tips
Replies
9
Views
1K
Dotty
Which size skillet is better for a family: 12 or 10?
  • linojackie
    • Products and Tips
Replies
16
Views
10K
chefann
Grill Pan vs. 12" Skillet: Which Cooks Chicken Better?
  • meganmcg
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
3K
rlombas
Using the 12" Exec Skillet: Do I Need the SS Skillet Too?
  • cochef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
Deb Bixler
Should I Choose a 10 or 12 Inch Skillet for My Kit Enhancement Month?
  • Intrepid_Chef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
29
Views
4K
kspry
Which Skillet is Best for Consultants?
  • Tracy99
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
rlombas
What size cookware should I choose with my cooking rewards?
  • NOLA RN
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
pattybrady
Which Is Better for My Kitchen: 12 Exec Skillet or Grill Pan?
  • sfdavis918
    • Products and Tips
Replies
19
Views
2K
ChefBeckyD
Citrus Press or Juicer Which Would You Choose?
  • jesusluvsu2005
    • Products and Tips
2
Replies
43
Views
4K
mconsola
Stainless Cookware - 12" Skillet
  • BadGirl
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
1K
Admin Greg
Back
Top