What is the difference between the black and green handle Santoku knives?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores the differences between the black and green handle Santoku knives, as well as the use of a meat thermometer for candy making. Participants share their experiences and insights regarding the quality and intended use of these products.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant mentions that the green handled knives are of lower quality compared to the black handled ones, which are forged cutlery with a lifetime warranty.
  • Another participant shares that the green knives are made from pressed stainless steel and are designed for casual cooks, while the black handled knives are made from heated, hammered steel for more durability.
  • Several users discuss the meat thermometer, with one stating it is not suitable for candy making due to its design and materials.
  • Another participant refers to the Product Info Guide, noting that while the thermometer can be used in scalding milk or frying oil, it is not intended for candy.
  • One participant expresses frustration about vague responses from seasoned consultants, emphasizing the importance of teaching new consultants how to find information effectively.
  • Another participant echoes this sentiment, highlighting the need for clear guidance for those unfamiliar with the community's terminology and resources.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ regarding the quality of the knives and the appropriate use of the meat thermometer, with no clear consensus emerging on these topics.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences and insights based on their interactions with the products and the community, reflecting a range of familiarity with the tools and resources available.

Who May Find This Useful

New consultants seeking clarification on product differences and usage, as well as those looking for guidance on navigating community resources.

fun2cook2
Messages
31
Good Morning, Everyone!
I have a customer who would like to buy a Santoku knife, but isn't sure if she wants the one with the black handle or the green one. What is the difference between the two?

Also, can the meat thermometer be used for candy?

Thanks so much for your help!
 
the green handled knives are not as good qualilty--the forged cutlery has a lifetime warranty.the meat thermometer is not meant for candy--nothing to hook it onto the pot with, the plastic would melt that hot, etc.
 
The PIG (Product Info Guide) says you can use it in scalding milk or fying oil (?surprises me), but it is not meant to be a candy thermometer.
 
The green knives are pressed stainless steel . They are designed for the person who is the kitchen 1-2 x's a week. The German Forged is heated, hammered steel- more strength, durabilty. They are made for the daily cook. The best thing to do is take the product classes on CC.
 
well said, loreo.
 
there is info on the differences between our knife collections behind CC.
 
DebbieJ said:
there is info on the differences between our knife collections behind CC.
I got a couple of these answers when I first started & it ticked me off because it didn't teach me how to find the answers in the future, it just left me scratching my head and irritated that more seasoned consultants were being vague. It's all about TEACHING them where to go to find the info so that they don't feel the need to come and ask in the future. This forum is for us to help them, not make them feel uncomfortable about asking questions.Fun2Cook2: When you sign in as a consultant, there is a search engine at the top right. Type in info about what you are looking for ... in this case I typed "compare knives" and this link popped up: https://www.pamperedchef.com/images/cc/us/pdf/compare_our_knife_collections.pdfThere are times when it's hard to find what you are looking for using that search engine, but more times than not, it can be a WEALTH of information.When you search for "thermometer", you'll find: https://www.pamperedchef.com/repsonly/product_information/use_care/detail.jsp?productId=27481There are also training videos that you should take to be a well informed consultant. To find those, sign in as a consultant, and on the main screen in the right column, you will see the link (it's the last one). ;)
 
  • Thread starter
  • #8
Thank you so much for your help, Shelia! I was trying to get a quick response and this site has been so helpful as I have started my business. Thank you for taking the time to respond and remembering what is is like being a newbie. (All the info. on each product can be a bit overwhelming. It's why I asked this morning, so I can get back to the customer asap.)

The thermometer had me all confused because of the product information guide. I thought I would ask in case anyone had used it for candy and they were successful. (Silly me!)
 
You are welcome! I don't make candy, but I've been told that it's not designed for that. ;)
 
Sheila said:
I got a couple of these answers when I first started & it ticked me off because it didn't teach me how to find the answers in the future, it just left me scratching my head and irritated that more seasoned consultants were being vague. It's all about TEACHING them where to go to find the info so that they don't feel the need to come and ask in the future. This forum is for us to help them, not make them feel uncomfortable about asking questions.

Gee, I thought I was being helpful--telling her where to find the answers. Guess not.
 
Sheila said:
I got a couple of these answers when I first started & it ticked me off because it didn't teach me how to find the answers in the future, it just left me scratching my head and irritated that more seasoned consultants were being vague. It's all about TEACHING them where to go to find the info so that they don't feel the need to come and ask in the future. This forum is for us to help them, not make them feel uncomfortable about asking questions.

Fun2Cook2: When you sign in as a consultant, there is a search engine at the top right. Type in info about what you are looking for ... in this case I typed "compare knives" and this link popped up: https://www.pamperedchef.com/images/cc/us/pdf/compare_our_knife_collections.pdf

There are times when it's hard to find what you are looking for using that search engine, but more times than not, it can be a WEALTH of information.

When you search for "thermometer", you'll find: https://www.pamperedchef.com/repsonly/product_information/use_care/detail.jsp?productId=27481

There are also training videos that you should take to be a well informed consultant. To find those, sign in as a consultant, and on the main screen in the right column, you will see the link (it's the last one). ;)

As usual, WELL said Sheila ;) :)
 
Thanks JodiDeb, it's just that sometimes there are answers posted that seem to be more of a "go look it up & quit bothering us" vs. actually teaching them how and where to find the info. The more seasoned consultants understand the lingo and we can be more vague. But that doesn't work as well with brand new people. Look at it this way, if you tell a 7 year old English speaking child or a 20 year old Japanese person "go make a salad", they are (more than likely) very capable of making the salad, but not without further instructions. If they've never seen a salad or they don't understand the language being used, the directive is of no use to them. Phrases like "there is info ... behind CC" is too vague for people who are new to all of this & don't understand that "behind CC" doesn't mean "behind credit card", etc. ;) New people really appreciate specific information on how to follow through with what they need to do. Now that I'm starting to feel like a more seasoned consultant, I hope that I can provide sufficient information to guide them vs. confusing or frustrating them. If I don't have time or the energy to sit & be specific, I just skip the post and let someone else do it. With a 1 year old & a 2 year old in the house, there are quite a few times that I'm just not mentally in a place to help. But I don't worry about it because I know that there are many other seasoned consultants here on the web board who can help. I just remember when I first started & would ask a question here, there were several times that the first response I received was a "go look it up" or "go watch the training videos" answer vs. actually answering the question or telling me how & where to find the answer. :( It was very frustrating back then and I've made it my goal to try and teach new consultants what I can so that they won't feel shunned like I did in the early days.
 
Sheila said:
Thanks Jodi

Deb, it's just that sometimes there are answers posted that seem to be more of a "go look it up & quit bothering us" vs. actually teaching them how and where to find the info. The more seasoned consultants understand the lingo and we can be more vague. But that doesn't work as well with brand new people. Look at it this way, if you tell a 7 year old English speaking child or a 20 year old Japanese person "go make a salad", they are (more than likely) very capable of making the salad, but not without further instructions. If they've never seen a salad or they don't understand the language being used, the directive is of no use to them. Phrases like "there is info ... behind CC" is too vague for people who are new to all of this & don't understand that "behind CC" doesn't mean "behind credit card", etc. ;) New people really appreciate specific information on how to follow through with what they need to do. Now that I'm starting to feel like a more seasoned consultant, I hope that I can provide sufficient information to guide them vs. confusing or frustrating them. If I don't have time or the energy to sit & be specific, I just skip the post and let someone else do it. With a 1 year old & a 2 year old in the house, there are quite a few times that I'm just not mentally in a place to help. But I don't worry about it because I know that there are many other seasoned consultants here on the web board who can help. I just remember when I first started & would ask a question here, there were several times that the first response I received was a "go look it up" or "go watch the training videos" answer vs. actually answering the question or telling me how & where to find the answer. :( It was very frustrating back then and I've made it my goal to try and teach new consultants what I can so that they won't feel shunned like I did in the early days.

Can I be YOU when I grow up? :D
 
roflmao2.gif
Sure you can! But it means you would have to come move 1/2 way around the world from your friends/family & live with MY husband!
 
Sheila said:
Thanks Jodi

Deb, it's just that sometimes there are answers posted that seem to be more of a "go look it up & quit bothering us" vs. actually teaching them how and where to find the info. The more seasoned consultants understand the lingo and we can be more vague. But that doesn't work as well with brand new people. Look at it this way, if you tell a 7 year old English speaking child or a 20 year old Japanese person "go make a salad", they are (more than likely) very capable of making the salad, but not without further instructions. If they've never seen a salad or they don't understand the language being used, the directive is of no use to them. Phrases like "there is info ... behind CC" is too vague for people who are new to all of this & don't understand that "behind CC" doesn't mean "behind credit card", etc. ;) New people really appreciate specific information on how to follow through with what they need to do. Now that I'm starting to feel like a more seasoned consultant, I hope that I can provide sufficient information to guide them vs. confusing or frustrating them. If I don't have time or the energy to sit & be specific, I just skip the post and let someone else do it. With a 1 year old & a 2 year old in the house, there are quite a few times that I'm just not mentally in a place to help. But I don't worry about it because I know that there are many other seasoned consultants here on the web board who can help. I just remember when I first started & would ask a question here, there were several times that the first response I received was a "go look it up" or "go watch the training videos" answer vs. actually answering the question or telling me how & where to find the answer. :( It was very frustrating back then and I've made it my goal to try and teach new consultants what I can so that they won't feel shunned like I did in the early days.

Sheila, you are just amazing! So very helpful and understanding to all us newbies. I have been doing PC a year now but am new to Chef Success and somtimes am like huh?? Everyone on here has been so fantastic but you take the cake...
 
hug.gif
Awe, thanks! I feel so loved!!!
hearts.gif
 
Sheila said:
I got a couple of these answers when I first started & it ticked me off because it didn't teach me how to find the answers in the future, it just left me scratching my head and irritated that more seasoned consultants were being vague. It's all about TEACHING them where to go to find the info so that they don't feel the need to come and ask in the future. This forum is for us to help them, not make them feel uncomfortable about asking questions.

Fun2Cook2: When you sign in as a consultant, there is a search engine at the top right. Type in info about what you are looking for ... in this case I typed "compare knives" and this link popped up: https://www.pamperedchef.com/images/cc/us/pdf/compare_our_knife_collections.pdf

There are times when it's hard to find what you are looking for using that search engine, but more times than not, it can be a WEALTH of information.

When you search for "thermometer", you'll find: https://www.pamperedchef.com/repsonly/product_information/use_care/detail.jsp?productId=27481

There are also training videos that you should take to be a well informed consultant. To find those, sign in as a consultant, and on the main screen in the right column, you will see the link (it's the last one). ;)

This link about the knives is incredible. I just read it all over and it is so helpful. I will be printing it off to put in binder. Thanks again Sheila.
 
Yes Thank you Shelia for taking the time to explain! I am in my 4th month and sometimes I am reading a post and people use abbreviations and I find myself flipping thru the catalog trying to figure out which product they are talking about!
Everyone is so helpful on here, keep up the good work girl! I love hearing your insite in things...and I think its amazing you are doing it all from Japan! hehe!
~Abigail
 
punkie1019 said:
This link about the knives is incredible. I just read it all over and it is so helpful. I will be printing it off to put in binder. Thanks again Sheila.

I'm glad the link helped! ;)

abigailhutch said:
Yes Thank you Shelia for taking the time to explain! I am in my 4th month and sometimes I am reading a post and people use abbreviations and I find myself flipping thru the catalog trying to figure out which product they are talking about!
Everyone is so helpful on here, keep up the good work girl! I love hearing your insite in things...and I think its amazing you are doing it all from Japan! hehe!
~Abigail

Thanks! :D
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between the black and green handle Santoku knives?

The primary difference between the black and green handle Santoku knives is the color of the handle. Both knives are designed with the same blade quality and functionality, but the handle color allows for personal preference in aesthetics.

Are the black and green handle Santoku knives made from the same materials?

Yes, both the black and green handle Santoku knives are made from the same high-quality materials. The blades are crafted from stainless steel, ensuring durability and sharpness, while the handles are designed for comfort and grip.

Do the black and green handle Santoku knives have different blade sizes?

No, both the black and green handle Santoku knives feature the same blade size. They are typically around 7 inches long, providing versatility for various cutting tasks in the kitchen.

Is there a price difference between the black and green handle Santoku knives?

No, there is no price difference between the black and green handle Santoku knives. Both options are priced the same, allowing customers to choose based on their color preference without worrying about cost.

Which handle color is more popular among customers?

Popularity can vary based on personal taste, but generally, both handle colors have their loyal fans. Some customers prefer the classic look of the black handle, while others enjoy the vibrant appearance of the green handle. Ultimately, it comes down to individual style.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Replies
16
Views
6K
Ginger428
Replies
19
Views
17K
The_Kitchen_Guy
  • dancedivine
  • Products and Tips
Replies
10
Views
11K
Michelle817
  • lacychef
  • Products and Tips
Replies
14
Views
2K
wadesgirl
  • Kenzie09
  • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
2K
AmyDare
  • mike nike
  • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
6K
pcsharon1
Replies
4
Views
2K
Staci
Replies
5
Views
2K
missydivine
  • gratergirl
  • Products and Tips
Replies
17
Views
2K
AJPratt
Replies
7
Views
1K
BethCooks4U
Back
Top