Cookies for the I.c. Sandwich Maker?

[avyd reader]

Does anyone know of a brand of store-bought cookies that are large enough to fill the ice cream sandwich maker or do I have to make them from scratch?

 

[ChefWatson]

I heard that the Archway cookies fit just right in them and if you are making them homemade then use the med. scoop.

 

[beepampered]

The deli cookies at our local Kroger store fit great.

 

[janel kelly]

I like the pillsbury cookie dough for the icsm. I get the big cookie pack that only comes in a dozen individual cookie doughs. To me they fit perfect.

 

[kltaylo]

I use the cookies from Sam's.

 

[pamperedalf]

Pepridge Farms soft bake work well, buy them at walmart they are cheaper. However you only get 4 sandwichs to a package.

 

[avyd reader]

Thanks so much for all of the help! I bought really expensive cookies today, but the cookies weren't large - just the package! I was disappointed about it, but I knew you guys would have the answer. Thanks again!

 

[LisaAnn]

I use the Pepperidge Farm Soft Batch cookies as well. For me soft cookies and hard ice cream work best. I put in 1 cookie, big scoop of ice cream then the other cookie and press it down a bit, flip it over on a bar board then smoosh it with the plunger, I think a hard cookie would probably crack if you did it this way. I also cut them in half using the crinkle cutter.

 

[jenniferlynne]

I didn't see this thread until after I went out and bought the "break-apart" cookie dough from Pillsbury. The regular size is way to small. I have a Kids party Saturday and I offered to bring the cookies for the ice cream sandwiches. I'm so glad you all started this thread! Off to the store again!!