PC Fanatic's Dilemma: Thrown Away Fluted Stoneware Pan - What Would You Do?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores participants' reactions to a situation involving a fluted stoneware pan that was discarded due to mouse droppings. Participants share their thoughts on how to handle customer concerns and the ethics of addressing such incidents.

Discussion Character

  • Opinion-based
  • Anecdotal
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant shares that they would have thrown away the pan due to hygiene concerns and would have contacted the company on behalf of the customer for a replacement.
  • Another participant emphasizes the importance of customer satisfaction and suggests contacting the company for guidance while also considering offering discounts to maintain customer loyalty.
  • One participant notes that it is unrealistic to expect a company to replace an item that was contaminated due to circumstances beyond their control but still advocates for asking the customer how they would like to proceed.
  • Another participant expresses appreciation for the approach of asking customers what they want rather than making assumptions about their needs.
  • One participant recounts their experience of overhearing the customer's story and clarifying misconceptions about the stoneware's properties, while also offering a discount for a new purchase.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ on the appropriateness of expecting a replacement for the discarded pan and the best approach to customer service in such situations. No clear consensus emerges.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences and opinions regarding customer interactions and the handling of product issues, reflecting a range of perspectives on service ethics and customer care.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants looking for insights on customer service approaches and handling product-related concerns may find this discussion relevant.

I
I Have the Tools
Messages
50
A guest at my show today (who loves PC and has a lot of it) said that she had the fluted stoneware pan for just a few days and a mouse pooped and peed on it, so she threw it away.

Said she couldn't stand the thought of using it.

I think I understood her to say that the consultant suggested she break it and say she broke it. Which she could not be dishonest and do (applaud for her). Since she had it such a short time, I think HO would have made her happy. (She didn't say it was PC's fault though, or course).

What would you as her consultant have done? And if you were her, would you have thrown it away?

Just wondering.

Kris
 
As a person, I would have definitely tossed a stone that had mouse droppings. Yech! Not even bleach would decontaminate it enough for my comfort.

As her consultant, I would have contacted HO on her behalf to see if anything could be done, telling them the truth about needing a replacement. To suggest she deliberately break it then try to pass it off as an accident is very dishonest. I know HO is very generous with their replacement policies, but to lie to them... Makes me wonder about that consultant's character.
 
Try to make her happy!!I think the expression:
"The customer is always right!"
is really a good policy to have. No matter what our customers deserve our help in anything that comes up. Sometimes life does bring crazy things at us and in order to keep a happy and returning customer we should always do whatever we possibly can to help them out.
Calling HO would be a great start. Get their ideas and policies on this and see what you can do. Also if HO cannot help, offer the customer a discount on a new stone purchase. I would even go so far as to offering her a stone for half off with a kitchen show or a catalog show that brings in at least $200. Kit enhancement month is coming and 40% off really helps if you choose to do that. If she books a show in April or after this discount will help you and really impress her with your caring attitude.
She seemed to understand that the situation was not anyone's fault except for nature itself. What a nice lady to deal with. Some people get irate and want to blame everyone around them.
Debbie
 
ASK what they want...do not assumeI always say that we should never assume what the customer wants. Why did she tell you about the mouse droppings? It is completely unrealistic to expect a company to take back an item because SHE allowed a mouse to use it as a restroom. That doesn't mean I would not have tried to do something for her though. Perhaps she was just telling you that story to point out the dishonest consultant. So...ASK..."How could I have made you feel better about that?" and listen to what they say. Every time I've done that, the customer has always asked for much less than what I was about to give them! They had a stone that broke? Don't immediately tell them to bring it to you and you'll take care of it! Ask them "How can I help you with that? Let me tell you about the return policy." Don't assume...just ask!
 
  • Thread starter
  • #5
I like that approach affshea. I'll remember it in the future.
She wasn't actually telling me she was talking to my sister and her daughter about it and as I was doing something else with someone I overheard her so it got my interest. She was in no way blaming the stone or PC or anyone, just stating that sadly this is what happened. She owns a lot of PC and is a fantastic cook I'm told. As well as a very sweet lady.

But what got my attention was when I heard, "...because you know the stones absorb EVERYTHING so I had to throw it away...."
So calmly I felt the need to nicely correct that statement. That because of the high temperatures they are fired at that they are non-porous. I didn't want folks having the wrong information.

She doesn't have a phone so I let her daughter know (my niece in law) to let her know that I'd be glad to let her purchase a new one at my discount. (After seeing this idea on here). She was in no way unhappy or being critical, just saying how awful it was that a mouse had gotten to it.

Kris
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the "PC Fanatic's Dilemma" about?

The "PC Fanatic's Dilemma" refers to a scenario where a dedicated Pampered Chef fan accidentally throws away their beloved fluted stoneware pan, leading to a discussion about what steps they should take next. It highlights the emotional attachment many have to their Pampered Chef products and the dilemma of replacing or trying to recover the lost item.

What should I do if I accidentally throw away my fluted stoneware pan?

If you accidentally throw away your fluted stoneware pan, the first step is to check your trash or recycling bin to see if it can be recovered. If it’s not retrievable, consider reaching out to Pampered Chef for advice on replacement options or any available discounts for loyal customers.

Can I replace my fluted stoneware pan if it's been discontinued?

If your fluted stoneware pan has been discontinued, you may still find it through secondary markets such as eBay, Facebook Marketplace, or local buy/sell groups. Additionally, Pampered Chef occasionally reintroduces popular items, so it's worth checking their official website or contacting a consultant for updates.

How can I prevent losing my Pampered Chef items in the future?

To prevent losing your Pampered Chef items, consider designating a specific storage area for your kitchen tools and bakeware. Keeping an inventory list or taking photos of your items can also help you keep track of what you have. Additionally, being mindful during clean-up can reduce the chances of accidentally discarding valuable items.

Are there any tips for caring for my Pampered Chef stoneware to avoid damage?

To care for your Pampered Chef stoneware and avoid damage, always follow the manufacturer's instructions. This includes avoiding drastic temperature changes, using utensils that won't scratch the surface, and properly cleaning with mild soap and water. Regular seasoning can also help maintain its non-stick qualities and longevity.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

What Would You Do? Is It Hopeless?
  • pamperedchef88
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
8
Views
2K
chefsteph07
Replacement Hope for Broken Bar Pan on Granite Countertop
  • momnixon
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
9
Views
21K
pampered1224
Is the Mini Muffin Pan from PC Defective?
  • PamperedDor
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
6
Views
2K
Bluiydangl
Ok All You Creative People Out There, How Would I Do This?
  • Nanisu
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
12
Views
2K
Intrepid_Chef
Lying for a Free Piece of Stoneware
  • lisasfuncooking
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
19
Views
3K
pcchefjane
What Would You Do in This Host Nightmare?
  • pcmom2abm
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
4
Views
1K
finley1991
What Would You Do? Navigating a Host's Order Before Vacation
  • Intrepid_Chef
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
16
Views
2K
Intrepid_Chef
What Would You Do if Someone Hung up on You?
  • cmdtrgd
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
15
Views
2K
DebbieSAChef
Lost SS Pan: Adjustment, Fed Ex Pickup, What Would You Do?
  • Jennie4PC
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
4
Views
1K
AnaCash
How Do You Handle Returning Broken Items for Customers?
  • jenniferlynne
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
2
Replies
39
Views
4K
elizabethfox
Back
Top