Check Out Costco's Top-of-the-Line Knives!

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores participants' experiences and opinions regarding knives available at Costco compared to those offered by Pampered Chef. Participants share their thoughts on quality, pricing, and personal preferences related to knife purchases.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant, identifying as a consultant, mentions seeing a set of three knives at Costco that looked similar to Pampered Chef's but were offered at a lower price.
  • Another participant shares their experience of being tempted to purchase the Costco knives but ultimately deciding to wait for Pampered Chef products.
  • Several participants express the view that Pampered Chef knives are superior in quality and design compared to the Costco options.
  • One participant notes that Pampered Chef knives come with a lifetime guarantee, while questioning if the Costco knives have a similar return policy.
  • Another participant emphasizes the importance of using and believing in Pampered Chef products for credibility with customers.
  • Some participants discuss the potential perception issues of buying Costco knives as Pampered Chef consultants.
  • One participant mentions that their husband, who is a chef, compared Pampered Chef knives to professional knives and found them to be of high quality.
  • Another participant highlights the ergonomic design of Pampered Chef knives as a distinguishing feature.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ among participants, with some advocating for waiting to earn Pampered Chef knives while others express a willingness to consider the Costco options. No clear consensus emerges on whether to purchase the Costco knives.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences and opinions based on their interactions with both Pampered Chef and Costco products, reflecting their individual preferences and financial situations.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants considering knife purchases or comparing products may find the shared experiences and opinions relevant to their decision-making process.

maryhenderlite
maryhenderlite
Messages
306
Ok, I know that our knifes are suppossed to be "top of the line" and I haven't held one in my hand yet.. but yesterday I went to Costco. They have a set of 3 knifes, that look identical to ours.. (just different writing on blade) I even pulled the new catalog our of my tote, and was showing my hubby. The Costco knifes come with the covers and everything. I know that I won't be able to afford all these new nice products as we are closing on our house within a week, and that is quite an expense... but I was very tempted to get them (didn't but very well may go back) The knifes were 49.99 for a set of 3 (all of them forged and everything) plus you get a coupon for $10 off. Even my hubby was impressed. They had one out just in a plasic case so you couldn't get cut. It was extremely heavy and felt really nice. I know it isn't PC, but for the price, I think it is worth a try.. The sizes were 9.5 inches, 7.5 inches and 5 inch (i think).. Just wanted to share.. I know that on the coupon it said that it was valid until 8-13. You guys may wanna check them out.:)
 
Don't do it! Even if you can't afford the PC knives, wait until you can earn them for free or at a great discount. Plus, don't foget you'll get paid commission.

Jeanie
 
I agree...If you have to wait until October to earn them as a host bonus or a half price item. Don't buy the knock off.
 
WAIT!!!! Just earn them!!! I saw the very same things at COSTCO.... my future hubby said they looked kind of cheep and PC's new knifes are way better looking!!!!! after all PC's arent' made in China? Are they?
 
mommyhugz1978 said:
WAIT!!!! Just earn them!!! I saw the very same things at COSTCO.... my future hubby said they looked kind of cheep and PC's new knifes are way better looking!!!!! after all PC's arent' made in China? Are they?
Click to expand...
YES OUIR KNIVES ARE MADE IN CHINA. SAYS SO ON THE BOX AND ON THE SIDE OF THE KNIFE
 
Even still, ours have a lifetime guarantee. Do the Costco ones? If you can return them at any time for any reason for a full refund, do it. See if you can borrow one from another consultant and compare them side-by-side. That way you can tell your customers why ours are better and that you actually had both kinds in your hands. Then make sure to return the Costco ones :D
 
Well I am not going to tell my future hubby that their made in China.... he wouln't let me buy them other wise!!
 
The new Forged Cutlery knives were made in Germany, probably right along side the Henkel knives that they are similar to!!!
 
stephanieboyd said:
The new Forged Cutlery knives were made in Germany, probably right along side the Henkel knives that they are similar to!!!
Click to expand...

No they're not. They're made of German steel, but right on the knife it says "made in China".:rolleyes:
 
I would also wait. My reasons are pretty stupid, but what if one of your customers saw you buying them or someone saw them at your house. Why should they buy PC knives if you won't even buy them?
 
I am biased here, my hubby works for Costco and they have an excellent return policy (even without the receipt) I was at Costco today and saw the coupon for the knives, I couldn't belive it!!! This also happened when our roasting pan came out, Costco had almost the same one and a lot cheaper. I told my husband "but PC has the lifetime guarantee" His reply "Your not happy with it, bring it back." Men can be so poetic! However, he loves the new paring knife! I earned it in the June sell-a-thon, and his exact words were "this knife is wicked." So I will be waiting and getting the PC knives when I can. I have realized my family and friends tend to buy whatever I have in my own kitchen, and they can see how many times in one party I use my batter bowl, measure all and small mix n scraper! WOOHOOO LOVE PC can''t wait to have a super September.
 
My husband, a chef, taught a little "knife" session for our cluster. He compared the new PC knives to those used by professional chefs. He said they were equal to the professiomal knives. He loves them, although he thinks the blade might be a little thick on the paring knife. We plan to get ours, like others have suggested, FREE. He really wants the Chef Knife and the Santoku. He was surprised they weren't selling the special garnishing knives that is in his culinary school knife set.

Trish
Wave ~ 1 at Chicago Hilton
I will recruit 5 people this month
 
no matter how much they look the same-you know they won't BE the same.
 
I thought I saw the knives on opem stock....for half off?
 
  • Thread starter
  • #15
Well, I know that I won't be able to purchase the PC knifes anytime soon. I am planning on getting one in the sample package I am getting.. I just know that I can't afford to then them any time soon. Doubt I'll be going back to costco, but they were very nice. Just wanted to let you all know about it. Like Tina said, they do have an excellent return policy.. Even though I love all my PC stuff, I just don't think I'll be able to get the new knifes... unless when I move, (new town, 6 hours away) I can really step up my business right away.
 
chefmelody said:
No they're not. They're made of German steel, but right on the knife it says "made in China".:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Actually the forged steel is made in Germany but the knives are assembled in China.
The letters on the knives mean. The cr means chrome, m- is molly (short form), and v is vandium.

the chrome is like the metal used in armoured cars
molly is used in making razor blades so sharp
and vandium is used to take gases out of the metals.

Most knives are cut or stamped out with a template, whereas forged cutlery are heated and hammered out. The quality in our cutlery is truly outstanding and an art.
 
Just think to yourself, that when you use a PC knife, you can sell it. You can't sell a Costco knife.
 
The picture doesn't do justice!I was shopping at Costco yesterday (BTW - I buy alot of things in bulk there that I can use for show recipes - cheaper!), so I made a point of checking out their knives.....I have the paring knife, utility knife, and Chef's knife.....and thier knives are not nearly the quality that ours are! The Handle isn't ergonomic like ours - and the knifes are lighter weight. Plus, it is a set of 3 Santoku knives - so there isn't the same variety of sizes and shapes...I think that you would be very disappointed if you purchased these and then compared them side-by-side with PC knives!
 
I haven't seen the Costco knives, but my experience tells me that most things that look the same as Pampered Chef, aren't.

As for the new knives, I've been drooling over some knives similar to the Santoku for about four years. I have never seen one of good quality for less than $100, and they are often over $200. I ordered the Santoku as soon as it became available. I have used it nearly every day. It is excellent! The weight and balance of the new knives is comparable to those sold to professional chefs.

Like several other consultants said, people look to see if we believe in the products enough to purchase and use them ourselves. It's one of my best selling points. It's also the best way to learn about the products so I can share useful tips at my shows, with my friends and family, etc.
 
Who all has qualified for the 2 knives this month? I will have by the end of this month!! I am so excited, and your right, PC knives cut like no other knife I have ever used. My brother and his wife just ordered a big set from a host. We can't wait to see the new knives when they arrive.
 
I qualified & received my SS1 bonus, but no knives yet. :(
 
Can we order the Santoku knife at more of a discount than our 22% before October?
 
tina_rn said:
Who all has qualified for the 2 knives this month? I will have by the end of this month!! I am so excited, and your right, PC knives cut like no other knife I have ever used. My brother and his wife just ordered a big set from a host. We can't wait to see the new knives when they arrive.
Click to expand...


Huh? Are the two knives the consultant incentive this month for you guys?
 
jwpamp said:
Can we order the Santoku knife at more of a discount than our 22% before October?
Click to expand...
Yes. If you hold a show of at least $300 in September you can get it as a half price item.
 
kcjodih said:
Huh? Are the two knives the consultant incentive this month for you guys?
Click to expand...
Anyone who signed in July or August and qualifies before September 30th will get the Santoku and Chef's knives.
 
BethCooks4U said:
Yes. If you hold a show of at least $300 in September you can get it as a half price item.
Click to expand...
Just the consultants can get this as the half priced in September? I'm so sorry, but I don't understand! Please help, Beth!:o
 
jwpamp said:
Just the consultants can get this as the half priced in September? I'm so sorry, but I don't understand! Please help, Beth!:o
Click to expand...
No any host can get it! But it's the only way we can get it for 50% off too.
 
maryhenderlite said:
unless when I move, (new town, 6 hours away) I can really step up my business right away.
Click to expand...

Mary, when you get to your new home, scout out the local library, and other public places and post "new pc consultant!" flyers, as well as postcards/flyers with the awesome september stoneware special (that everyone is raving about in the booking section) ... I know you'll be busy, but try to drum up some business right away -- your efforts will pay off, and maybe you can earn those knives after all! plus, christmas will only be a few months away, so you'll have extra money for that from all of your awesome commission! :D
 
Awesome! Awesome! Awesome!I bought some corn on the cob at a local farm market today. My hubby has false teeth and has a hard time eating corn on the cob. I got my 3 1/2" paring knife out of the box to use to cut it off the cob. I was just like cutting butter, baby!! Unbelievable. I cut corn off two cobs in about 1 minute flat. I was really surprised. On the first cut corn went flying everywhere because I didn't expect it to cut so easy. i'm so excited about my knives.
 
A great tip for cutting corn off the ears... place the cob on the middle piece of the fluted pan and cut the corn off... the kernels fall right into the pan :)
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Costco's top-of-the-line knives stand out from other brands?

Costco's top-of-the-line knives are known for their high-quality materials, exceptional craftsmanship, and competitive pricing. They often feature stainless steel blades that offer durability and sharpness, ergonomic handles for comfort, and are designed for both professional chefs and home cooks.

Are Costco's knives worth the investment?

Yes, many customers find that Costco's knives provide excellent value for the price. They combine quality and affordability, making them a worthwhile investment for anyone looking to upgrade their kitchen tools without breaking the bank.

How do I care for and maintain my Costco knives?

To maintain your Costco knives, it's essential to hand wash them with mild soap and warm water, avoiding the dishwasher. Regularly honing the blades with a honing steel and occasionally sharpening them will help keep them in optimal condition. Proper storage in a knife block or magnetic strip can also prevent damage.

Can I return knives to Costco if I'm not satisfied?

Yes, Costco has a generous return policy that allows members to return items, including knives, if they are not satisfied. It's advisable to keep the original packaging and receipt for a smoother return process.

Do Costco's knives come with a warranty?

Many of Costco's top-of-the-line knives come with a manufacturer's warranty, which typically covers defects in materials and workmanship. It's important to check the specific warranty details for each knife set to understand the coverage and duration.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Sharpening Knives: Does it Work for All Brands?
  • Leigh0725
    • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
9K
pchefkristin
? Re: Exec Cookware Vs. Prof Line/Knives
  • pcleah
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
nikked
Video of All the Spring/Summer Line
  • Sheila
    • Products and Tips
Replies
27
Views
4K
Intrepid_Chef
Discovering the Least Favorite Products from SL's New SA Line
  • Brenda.the.chef
    • Products and Tips
2 3
Replies
66
Views
16K
pchockeymom
Must-Have" List for Pampered Chef Lovers
  • hoosierchef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
1K
sarahlegare
Finding Cookware for MIL: Professional Line vs. 2005 Non-Lifetime Warranty
  • maldvs
    • Products and Tips
Replies
12
Views
3K
pampered1224
How Do You Guys Handle Check Out?
  • nickywsn
    • Products and Tips
Replies
26
Views
3K
jrstephens
Who Wants a New Vacuum Cleaner??? Check This Out
  • crissy11
    • Products and Tips
Replies
18
Views
2K
climbercanoe3
Discover the Capacity of our Small Oval Baker - Perfect for Your Cooking Needs!
  • kcjodih
    • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
2K
Staci
Check Your Utensils: Quality Made in the USA!
  • afshea
    • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
2K
Staci
Back
Top