Is Your Pizza Stone Perfectly Seasoned? Tips and Tricks for Optimal Results!

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The thread explores participants' experiences and observations regarding the seasoning of pizza stones and other stoneware. Participants share their personal journeys with seasoning, the differences they notice, and the factors that may affect the seasoning process.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant, identifying as a consultant, expresses excitement about realizing their stones are perfectly seasoned, noting frequent use.
  • Another participant shares their enjoyment in watching their stones season, mentioning a small round stone that had been underutilized.
  • Several users mention that stoneware seasons differently based on usage, with some areas remaining unseasoned due to food placement.
  • One participant describes their experience with a large round stone that is not seasoning evenly, seeking advice on this issue.
  • Another participant reflects on their long-term use of a rectangular stone, which took years to season properly due to infrequent use.
  • Some participants discuss the appearance of well-seasoned stones, with one noting that a neighbor's stone is completely black, while others clarify that a well-seasoned stone should be dark brown.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ regarding the best practices for achieving optimal seasoning, with no clear consensus on whether certain methods or storage practices are more effective.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences with various types of stoneware, highlighting the variability in seasoning based on individual usage patterns and cooking habits.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants interested in understanding the nuances of stoneware seasoning and those looking to share experiences with fellow users may find this discussion relevant.

itsjustCarla
Messages
648
...when you come to the realization that your stones are PERFECTLY SEASONED and you didn't even realize it??

I haven't had mine long, but use them frequently. I got two of them out the other day and ding! ding! ding! and I'm like...wow!

I know, I know.....sounds kinda geeky....LOL
 
You're a true PC-addict when you get all geeked about black stones and the like! Congrats!!
 
I love watching my stones season. I have a small round stone that was only used in the microwave that I started using in the oven because it looked so lonely against all my seasoned stones. I also have a new bar pan that I've been trying to use like crazy to get it nice and seasoned. Just wish I could use my fluted pan more so that it will season up.

Katie, I agree with seeing some of my customers with black stones. You cannot even tell what they really are until you look at them. If I know that the host has one, I'll ask if I can hold it up when I talk about the stoneware. That's a stone to be really proud of!
 
Quick question - my large round stone (that came in kit 5 yrs ago) is not seasoning evenly. Is that normal? I didn't own PC prior to signing. It is brown on outside edge & directly in the center but has a lighter ring around middle. Also, med. bar pan is seasoning around edges but not at all on the bottom. I have used the shortening/salt method but it didn't do much. Any tips/suggestions? I still love them! They are super!
 
Stoneware will season differently. If you are used to cooking pizzas or rings on the round stone, it won't season where the food covers it. That's what it sounds like. The bar pan could be from making bars or cakes in it. On my medium bar pan you can tell where we normally place two chicken breasts to cook, there's round circles (breaded and stuffed chicken breasts) right in the center of the stone.
 
wadesgirl said:
I love watching my stones season. I have a small round stone that was only used in the microwave that I started using in the oven because it looked so lonely against all my seasoned stones. I also have a new bar pan that I've been trying to use like crazy to get it nice and seasoned. Just wish I could use my fluted pan more so that it will season up.

Katie, I agree with seeing some of my customers with black stones. You cannot even tell what they really are until you look at them. If I know that the host has one, I'll ask if I can hold it up when I talk about the stoneware. That's a stone to be really proud of!


I do the same thing - I make a big deal out of it, and tell the guests that Suzie Host has a well-loved stone.

It's okay Carla - I am very proud of my perfectly seasoned stones too!
 
wadesgirl said:
Stoneware will season differently. If you are used to cooking pizzas or rings on the round stone, it won't season where the food covers it. That's what it sounds like. The bar pan could be from making bars or cakes in it. On my medium bar pan you can tell where we normally place two chicken breasts to cook, there's round circles (breaded and stuffed chicken breasts) right in the center of the stone.

Is there a way to season it completely? My neighbor's is completely black & she has only had hers for about 3 years. Mine is 5 years old.
 
stacywhitlow said:
Is there a way to season it completely? My neighbor's is completely black & she has only had hers for about 3 years. Mine is 5 years old.

I guess it is how you use it...my rectangular stone is about 10-12 years old and it is FINALLY just getting seasoned well...of course I didn't use it much for about 5-7 years of that time! :eek:

I bought stones in the beginning but didn't cook much and wasn't "taught" about the usage so it took me awhile. Now I have "brand new" stones getting seasoned as much as my older stones...

Also, I've broken a few over the years. :( Like my large round one...and my mini baker...and my first bar pan... :cry:

My most seasoned are:
1. rectangular stone
2. older classic 9x13 baker (my lasagna stone I call it...)
3. my old classic DDB (the bowl/lid doesn't look like a match anymore!)
4. My lid for the classic 9x13 because I've used it for lasagna and roasts and other things...
5. And now my bar pan and DCB are catching up!!!!!!!!!!!
 
stacywhitlow said:
Is there a way to season it completely? My neighbor's is completely black & she has only had hers for about 3 years. Mine is 5 years old.

Most people who have "black" stones are leaving them in the oven even when it's not in use. That's not recommended. I mean you can store it in there, but take it out when you are baking and not using it. That is typically how they turn black.

A true well seasoned stone should be a really dark brown, no matter how long you use it. It shouldn't actually turn black.
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What does it mean for a pizza stone to be perfectly seasoned?

A perfectly seasoned pizza stone has a non-stick surface that enhances the flavor of your food while preventing sticking. Seasoning involves the process of baking oil into the stone, which creates a protective layer that improves its cooking performance over time.

How do I season my pizza stone?

To season your pizza stone, start by cleaning it thoroughly with a damp cloth to remove any dust or debris. Preheat your oven to 450°F (232°C), then apply a thin layer of vegetable oil or olive oil to the surface of the stone. Place the stone in the oven upside down and bake for about an hour. Allow it to cool completely before using it again.

How can I tell if my pizza stone is seasoned properly?

A well-seasoned pizza stone will have a darkened surface and a slightly oily feel. When you bake on it, your pizza should slide off easily without sticking, and the crust should come out crispy and evenly cooked. If you notice sticking or uneven cooking, it may need more seasoning.

Can I wash my pizza stone after seasoning it?

It is not recommended to wash your pizza stone with soap, as this can strip away the seasoning. Instead, allow it to cool after use, then scrape off any food residue with a spatula or brush. For stubborn stains, you can use a damp cloth or a scraper, but avoid soaking it in water.

How often should I season my pizza stone?

The frequency of seasoning your pizza stone depends on how often you use it. Generally, you should season it every few months or whenever you notice that food begins to stick or the surface looks worn. Regular use will naturally build up seasoning over time, enhancing its performance.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

  • bakinwithbacon
  • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
Admin Greg
Replies
11
Views
27K
Shawnna
Replies
10
Views
13K
wadesgirl
Replies
17
Views
7K
pctharper
Replies
9
Views
3K
chefann
Replies
18
Views
4K
BettieC
Replies
2
Views
1K
DebbieJ
Replies
2
Views
2K
mscharf
Replies
4
Views
3K
Chefgirl2
  • slapsappyhappy
  • Pampered Chef Stoneware
Replies
2
Views
2K
Admin Greg
Back
Top