Can Pie Shields Be Used on Both 9 and 8 Inch Pies?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores the compatibility of pie shields with different sizes of pie plates, specifically focusing on 8-inch and 9-inch options. Participants share their personal experiences regarding the fit and functionality of the pie shields with various types of pie plates.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based

Main Points Raised

  • One participant notes that the pie shield only works with Pampered Chef pie plates, as they are not standard sizes.
  • Another participant shares their experience of the pie shield not fitting well with their deep dish pie plate, expressing uncertainty about whether they were using it correctly.
  • Several users mention that the pie shield fits better on standard 9-inch pie plates compared to Pampered Chef pie stones, which they find deeper and more challenging to work with.
  • One participant describes the design of the pie shield, indicating that it fits loosely over the top and has cut-away sections for handles, suggesting that adjustments may be necessary for proper fit.
  • Another participant expresses that they do not recommend the pie shield due to its high return rate, while acknowledging that some users have positive experiences with it.
  • One participant mentions their mother-in-law's use of the pie shield with a deep dish pie plate but is unsure of her satisfaction with it.
  • A participant who recently used the pie shield for the first time shares their disappointment with the fit, noting it did not sit closely around the handles as expected.
  • One participant provides clarification on how the pie shield is intended to rest on the pie plate, emphasizing that it does not clamp down and is designed to prevent crust damage.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ regarding the effectiveness and fit of the pie shield with various pie plates, with no clear consensus emerging on its overall usability.

Contextual Notes

Participants' experiences vary based on the specific types of pie plates they use, highlighting the variability in fit and satisfaction with the product.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants and community members interested in personal experiences with pie shields and their compatibility with different pie plates may find this discussion relevant.

PCSarahjm
PCSarahjm
Messages
701
Does is work on 9 and 8 inch pies?
 
It only works on our pie plates because ours are not the standard size. So, if the dish you are looking at is the same width, it should work.
 
Not mine
cmdtrgd said:
It only works on our pie plates because ours are not the standard size. So, if the dish you are looking at is the same width, it should work.
Click to expand...

I got it specifically to work with my deep dish pie plate and it doesn't fit well at all...maybe I am doing something wrong??? :cry:
 
purrbal said:
I got it specifically to work with my deep dish pie plate and it doesn't fit well at all...maybe I am doing something wrong??? :cry:
Click to expand...

I find that mine actually works better with my plain old 9" pie plates. It doesn't work well for me with the PC Pie stones. I'm not a big fan of the pie stones......because they are deeper - I have to do too much adjusting of recipes to make them work in the stones.
 
It fits loosely over the top to give you room to put your crust over the top of the plate. There are two cut-away places that fit over the handles of the pie plate. If it isn't fitting, do an adjustment and get another one. Our stoneware is hand made, so there can be slight abnormalities.
 
cmdtrgd said:
It fits loosely over the top to give you room to put your crust over the top of the plate. There are two cut-away places that fit over the handles of the pie plate. If it isn't fitting, do an adjustment and get another one. Our stoneware is hand made, so there can be slight abnormalities.
Click to expand...

I have a cranberry, a vanilla, and a blue pie stone - doesn't work with any of them.
 
This is one of those products that I ALWAYS tell guests to try it out right away. This is probably my #1 returned item due to them not liking it. I will not reccommend it, but I don't go out of my way to bash it, either...since some folks have it and LOVE it!!
 
KellyTheChef said:
This is one of those products that I ALWAYS tell guests to try it out right away. This is probably my #1 returned item due to them not liking it. I will not reccommend it, but I don't go out of my way to bash it, either...since some folks have it and LOVE it!!
Click to expand...

Usually, I have people ask if they can use it with pie plates other than PC, and I just tell them that I do all the time!:D
 
My MIL has one to use with the DD pie plate & I haven't had her say anything to me about it. I'm not sure if that means she isn't using it or she is & loves it.:confused:
 
I just used mine for the first time and I don't love the way it fits the deep dish pie plate. I thought it would fit down around the handles more and sit closer to the crust. I've never made a pie before today so I can't compare it to anything else. However, my repsonse to it sounds similar to the rest so I suppose I didn't do anything wrong.
 
Kate is correct. The best thing to do is to look at the PCS picture in the catalog on p.47. That shows how it's supposed to "rest" on the top edge... It doesn't clamp down over the edge. It's great because if you have a shaped edge, it won't crush it or damage it. I always used to do that with foil! This just rests lightly on the edge and keeps the edges of the crust from overbrowning. Hope that helps!
 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can pie shields be used on both 9 and 8 inch pies?

Yes, pie shields are designed to be versatile and can typically be used on both 9-inch and 8-inch pies. However, it's important to check the specific dimensions of the pie shield to ensure a proper fit.

What is a pie shield?

A pie shield is a kitchen tool that helps protect the edges of a pie crust from burning while it bakes. It is usually made of metal or silicone and fits around the edge of the pie dish.

How do I use a pie shield?

To use a pie shield, place it around the edges of your pie before baking. This will prevent the crust from browning too quickly. You can remove it during the last 15-20 minutes of baking to allow the crust to finish browning.

Are there different sizes of pie shields?

Yes, pie shields come in various sizes to accommodate different pie dishes. It's important to select a pie shield that matches the size of your pie for optimal protection.

Can I make my own pie shield?

Yes, you can make a DIY pie shield using aluminum foil. Simply cut a piece of foil and shape it to fit around the edges of your pie crust, ensuring it covers the areas that may brown too quickly.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Customer Concerns: Discolored Pie Crust Shields
  • donnathepamperedchef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
rlombas
Pie-Making Tips & EAD Replacement Parts: Help Laurie Out!
  • lauriedip
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
lauriedip
Holiday Pie CuPampered Chefakes, and Other Yummy Pies
  • esavvymom
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
2
Views
1K
sharalam
Finding the Perfect Pie Plate: 9" (4cups) Edition
  • rennea
    • Products and Tips
Replies
5
Views
2K
smarteez2
Where Can I Find a 9 Inch Round Stoneware Cake Pan?
  • quiverfull7
    • Pampered Chef Stoneware
Replies
2
Views
4K
Admin Greg
Can the Make and Take Mason Jar Lid be used on a regular Mason Jar?
  • Lauren Powers
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
5K
Admin Greg
Is a Handle on Both Ends the Solution for the DBC?
  • Jennifer E
    • Products and Tips
Replies
11
Views
2K
lovescooking
Lots of Products and some materials for sale - Variety of New & Used
  • kcmckay
    • Sell Pampered Chef Items
Replies
4
Views
7K
Sheilainwv
Can We Order Some Samples Now and Some Later?
  • cathyskitchen
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
1K
DanaK
Metal Muffin Pan Cooks Too Dark!
  • scottcooks
    • Products and Tips
Replies
5
Views
3K
babywings76
Back
Top