Black vs Silver Serving Trays: A Comparison and Personal Preference

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread centers around a comparison of black and silver serving trays, with participants sharing their personal preferences and experiences regarding these products. There is some confusion about the specific items being discussed, leading to clarifications and anecdotes related to the trays.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Opinion-based
  • Anecdotal

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses a preference for black trays over silver, noting that the silver ones feel too fancy for their taste.
  • Another participant seeks clarification on the specific silver trays being referenced, mentioning brushed silver caddies and platters.
  • Several participants discuss the transition from black wrought iron stands to brushed stainless steel, indicating some confusion about the terminology used.
  • One participant shares their experience of puzzling over the discussion, reflecting on past products and potential mix-ups with other brands.
  • Another participant mentions the challenges of daily life, including caring for a spouse with Alzheimer's, and how this community provides a change of pace.
  • One participant offers to help another with a private message regarding the trays.
  • Another participant shares their experience of attending support groups for caregivers, highlighting the emotional challenges involved.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ on the specific products being discussed, with some participants expressing confusion about the terminology and others clarifying their understanding. No clear consensus emerges regarding the preference for black versus silver trays.

Contextual Notes

The discussion includes personal anecdotes related to caregiving and the emotional challenges faced by participants, which adds depth to the conversation about serving trays.

Who May Find This Useful

Participants in the consultant community who are interested in product comparisons or who share similar caregiving experiences may find this discussion relevant.

redsoxgirl
redsoxgirl
Messages
1,484
Somehow I missed the black trays! I didn't go to a PC for a few years and it must have been then that they were out.

I like those a lot better than the silver personally, although I'm not a fan of the heart handle.

I'll have to keep an eye out for them on the Outlet I suppose.

The silver are nice, but they're a little fancy for us I think. We're simple folk! LOL
 
Ok, what am I missing here???? I can't even think of what you are referring to....silver SA trays????? We had the black triangles several years ago, but what silver trays are you referring to? Are you meaning the caddies for the bowls and the rectangle platter? If so, they are brushed silver and go with any decor and the top has a slit for a card, like to describe what you are serving.
 
You are talking about the stands. For a while, they were black wrought iron. Now they are brushed stainless steel, not silver.
 
c00p said:
Ok, what am I missing here???? I can't even think of what you are referring to....silver SA trays????? We had the black triangles several years ago, but what silver trays are you referring to? Are you meaning the caddies for the bowls and the rectangle platter? If so, they are brushed silver and go with any decor and the top has a slit for a card, like to describe what you are serving.
Click to expand...
Took me a minute too - but I'm pretty sure she means the old black caddies vs. the brushed stainless ones we have now!
 
Thanks for clarifying this. I was trying to figure out what trays Lindsay was referring too.
 
the reference to the "heart handles" helped me figure it out!
 
Your mind is working quicker than mine today, Becky! LOL!!!!!
 
pamperedharriet said:
Your mind is working quicker than mine today, Becky! LOL!!!!!
Click to expand...

Nah - You don't know how long I puzzled over that post!:D :D :D
At first, I was thinking the old black SA triangles......but couldn't remember any time when we had silver triangles.....only the gold rimmed dessert plates.....and then I wondered if she was getting mixed up with Home Interiors or Home & Garden Party, or SLAH.......just color me confused.....:confused: :balloon: :D :D
 
And Lindsay - don't mind us......just being silly!:balloon:
 
It's nice when we all get stumped once in awhile--makes up put our thinking caps on. I have so many challenging moments here everyday (home, that is) with my DH not calling things by their proper names (he has Alzheimer's) and trying to figure out what he is talking about and try to come here for a change of pace.
 
pamperedharriet said:
It's nice when we all get stumped once in awhile--makes up put our thinking caps on. I have so many challenging moments here everyday (home, that is) with my DH not calling things by their proper names (he has Alzheimer's) and trying to figure out what he is talking about and try to come here for a change of pace.
Click to expand...

Harriet - I had no idea about DH! I know that is a huge challenge. My grandma had Alzheimers, and I used to go one weekend a month to stay with her to give grandpa a break.....it's a 24 hour a day job! Do you have a Support Group you can go attend? I know that really was a lifesaver for Grandpa.....
 
Lindsay,

I PMed you - I may be able to help you out.

Harriet, I am very sorry to hear about your husband. I can only imagine the challenges you and he face. You're in my prayers!
 
ChefBeckyD said:
Harriet - I had no idea about DH! I know that is a huge challenge. My grandma had Alzheimers, and I used to go one weekend a month to stay with her to give grandpa a break.....it's a 24 hour a day job! Do you have a Support Group you can go attend? I know that really was a lifesaver for Grandpa.....
Click to expand...

I try to go to a support group that meets twice a month. Sometimes I come home more stressed out than before I went as many are worse off than my DH in the group. I am working on getting him into an adult day care twice a week locally--I applied for a grant a month ago and haven't heard back yet.
He was diagnosed 4 years ago this past August and the past few months he has really started to show changes and I had his medication changed which is helping in some areas.

Some days are more challenging than others. Fortunately he is with it most of the time but had a scare this morning. While I was still sleeping he took our dog out and while he was out realized that he took her out without her leash, fortunatley when he realized it she wasn't too far away from him and came to him, he picked her up and brought her back inside and then put the leash on and took her out to do her business. I gave him credit for telling me about it when I woke up and told him that I was sorry it happened but it was good that it ended up OK and that maybe he needs to slow down and think about what he is doing. I was surprised that I didn't yell or shout but I guess I am learning how to deal with it better. Needless to say I have kept an extra eye on things around here today.

Thanks Becky and Diane for your concerns and prayers.

Sorry to hijack this thread.:o
 
  • Thread starter
  • #14
Oh man - sorry for the confussion guys!! Sometimes I think I have blonde roots ;)

PMd ya back Diane :)
 
I have all 3 stands in the iron if interested.
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between black and silver serving trays?

The main differences between black and silver serving trays include their color, material, and aesthetic appeal. Black trays often provide a modern and sleek look, while silver trays tend to offer a classic and elegant appearance. Additionally, the material used can affect durability and maintenance, with some black trays being made of plastic or coated metal, while silver trays are often made of stainless steel or aluminum.

Which serving tray is more versatile for different occasions?

Silver serving trays are generally considered more versatile due to their classic design, which can complement a variety of themes and settings, from formal events to casual gatherings. Black trays, while stylish, may be more suited for contemporary or themed occasions. Ultimately, the choice depends on personal preference and the specific event.

How do I choose between a black and silver serving tray for my home?

Choosing between a black and silver serving tray for your home depends on your existing decor and personal style. If your home features modern or minimalist design, a black tray may blend well. Conversely, if you have a more traditional or eclectic style, a silver tray might be a better fit. Consider the functionality and how often you plan to use the tray as well.

Are there any maintenance differences between black and silver serving trays?

Yes, there can be maintenance differences between black and silver serving trays. Black trays, especially those made of plastic, may require less maintenance but can show scratches or wear over time. Silver trays, while often more durable, may require regular polishing to maintain their shine and prevent tarnishing. It's essential to follow the manufacturer's care instructions for both types.

What is the personal preference trend among Pampered Chef customers regarding serving trays?

Among Pampered Chef customers, personal preference trends often lean towards silver serving trays for their timeless elegance and versatility. However, many customers also appreciate the modern aesthetic of black trays, especially for casual or themed events. Ultimately, the choice varies based on individual tastes, event types, and home decor styles.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Leaving the Business - 11 1/2 Years of Business Materials for Sale
  • chefamanda
    • Sell Pampered Chef Items
2 3
Replies
61
Views
14K
stephaniekocala
St. Patrick's Day Theme Ideas for a Fun and Festive Kitchen Show
  • DebPC
    • Pampered Chef Shows
Replies
8
Views
6K
GourmetGirl
Back
Top