What is the fair price for my consultant's leftover items?

[PampMomof3]

I have a consultant who went inactive about 3 months ago. At that time, she wanted to sell some of her stuff but I found the prices too much for me. I talked to her today and told her that I couldn't remember the prices and she said at this point, she's ready to pack the stuff up and store in the attic. She said to just offer a price.

So, I'm coming to you. WHat do you think and how much would you offer?

Kristi, here is the list of the items that I have left before I pack my boxes and store:

S/S '08 Catalogs pkg. of 25.....$15.00
Sales Recipts FN-13 09/07 95 shts.....$5.00
Order Forms JA-25 03/08 25 qty.....$?
Your Life Your Way DVD 8 qty....$8.00
S/S New Product Mini Catalog 25 qty. $2.00
Congrats on Starting Your New Business Brochure FN-24 09/07 20 qty...?
Start Strong... brochure FK-05R 03/07 36 qty...?
Your Life Your Way Brochure FN-19 09/07 38 qty.....$1.00
Your Life Your Way Brochure FK-07 03/07 21 qty.....$1.00
Planning Guide FN-31 09/07 22 qty. FREE
Planning Guide FK-08R2 03/07 10 qty. FREE
Wedding Registry Brochure FK-76 03/07 17 qty....?
Recipe Cards:
Bites & Bevs Tangy Pepper Pecan Brie 142 cards @ .025/ea
Real Food Real Fast Asian Pork & Noodle Skillet 138 cards @ .025/ea
Chocolate Bliss Warm Nutty Caramel Brownies 45 cards @ .025/ea
Sweet n Simple Mini-Glazed Lemon Cakes 30 cards @ .025/ea
6'o clock Salads Deluxe Cheeseburger Salad 30 cards @ .025/ea
Bags Catalog clear .... tba have to find my receipt on what I paid for them
Door Slip FK-03 03/07 3 pads ?
Invitations:
Your Invited to a Cooking Show FK-01 03/07 277 cards @ 5.54/lot
Real Food Real Fast FN-82 09/07 120 cards @ 2.40/lot
Join the Celebration BP-20 09/04 (OLD) 80 cards @ $1.00/lot
Join Me (GENERIC/OLD) PF-43 11/03 280 cards @ $3.50/lot

As you can see I discounted some things, I also did not know how to price a few things out (you will them italized and have a ? mark), can you help me clarify before you submit to the others. I will try and find my price for the bags by tomorrow evening, I have to look through a few things.

 

[PampMomof3]

Anyone have any ideas of how much to offer her?

 

[chefkathy]

I would take retail price and cut it in half. Some of her things are WAYYYY too high!

 

[ChefLisa]

I'm with Deb.

 

[dannyzmom]

Ditto what Deb & Lisa said

 

[BethCooks4U]

I wouldn't pay more than $12 for the catalogs. That's what I sell them to my team for if I have extras and they need them. ($45/4 = $11.25. I round it up to $12 to cover tax - actual cost to me $12.01. I know I am eating shipping but then I am their director.)

I agree her prices are high on the other things too.

 

[PampMomof3]

I would take retail price and cut it in half. Some of her things are WAYYYY too high!

That's exactly why I didn't buy them sooner. I thought they were ridicously high and I wouldn't pay it. So, I don't want it to be a slap in the face and say too low but I don't want to pay an arm and a leg either. Ugh!