Frustrated with New Recruit: Is My Effort Wasted? | Venting Session

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread centers around a participant's frustrations with a new recruit who has not engaged with the business despite being signed on for a month. Various participants share their experiences and opinions regarding the recruit's lack of activity and potential motivations.

Discussion Character

  • Opinion-based
  • Anecdotal
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses frustration over their recruit not opening their starter kit and not taking action despite attending events.
  • Another participant questions whether the recruit has legitimate bookings, suggesting that she may be a "kit-napper."
  • One participant shares their experience of offering incentives to their recruit, who has studied the products but struggles to get started.
  • Several participants note that new recruits often face challenges in booking shows and may not have had any scheduled initially.
  • One participant recounts their own experience of being pressured into signing without having shows booked, highlighting the difficulties of starting out.
  • Another participant mentions the importance of understanding the recruit's goals and encouraging them to take action.
  • One participant suggests that the recruit may need a conversation to clarify her intentions and set an action plan.
  • Another participant shares a strategy used by their director to help recruits engage with their kits, which included a questionnaire and incentives.
  • One participant reflects on the challenges of managing multiple recruits and the impact of one recruit's inactivity on their own business.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ among participants regarding the recruit's intentions and potential as a consultant. Some express concern about her lack of action, while others suggest she may simply need more support and encouragement.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences related to recruiting and starting in the business, illustrating the varied challenges faced by new consultants.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to consultants navigating similar challenges with new recruits or those seeking insights into motivating team members.

kisrae
kisrae
Gold Member
Messages
482
I have a new recruit who has signed a month ago and hasn't done a thing with the business.
I invited her to a fair to get leads, coached her in making calls, she came to two cluster meetings, she came to a show with me last night and I found out :eek: SHE HASN'T OPENED HER STARTER KIT!:eek: Well to be fair she didn't tell me she hasn't open her kit but she asked which pan was in her set. I looked a little shocked.

I'm just getting worn out. I have two other recruits who work their business.

Thanks for the vent.
 
Are you sure she even has legitimate bookings? She should've had 4-6 bookings on her contract!

When I first started, my upline director asked for my bookings. She then sent a letter to each hostess herself, thanking them for helping me get started. After the show was held and submitted, she then sent each of them a Mini-serving spatula as a small thank you.

You may want to consider something similar, if it will help...?

Sorry, but she is starting to sound like a "kit-napper"!! I hope I'm wrong!

Best wishes,
Paula
 
  • Thread starter
  • #3
I am going to offer her some incentive, but she put in dates for her contract and has done TONS of studying and reading on the products and Pampered chef. But just cant get going.
 
But the question remains...where are her first 4-6 hostesses? Shouldn't she have done their shows by now?

The dates for her first shows should have been in the first 30 days. If she is already past that time frame, what's going on?

If you think she's really going to do this, you may want to see if she is able to change her start date. We used to be able to move it ahead by one month, before the new Super Starter program came out. I don't know if it's still available now, though, since it's a new program. To do it in the past, she had to submit a written request to Field Services. It could even be done via email. Other than that, however, I don't know what to tell you, other than to be a little suspicious at this point, perhaps?

I've had the unfortunate experience of signing a few "kit-nappers"...or, as I prefer to call them...."liars and thieves"!! They are not pleasant to deal with, and it really irks me when it happens. (can you tell? lol)

I hope she isn't one of THEM.....:0)

Good luck to you!
Paula
 
When I first signed on with PC I didn't know anything before hand about what or how to do anything, so I just had to make up some dates to put on the contract. I'm still here 18 months later. That person might not have had any shows ready to book either, but just wanted to join. Would you refuse to let someone sign the contract if they didn't have 4 shows booked? I wouldn't.
 
When I first signed up, I didn't have any shows scheduled. I felt like I was pressured into signing the contract that day. My director filled in the dates knowing I didn't have a single show scheduled. A whole month went by and I had no shows scheduled, it wasn't because I wasn't trying, I just was so new I couldn't get any shows. I actually had to change my first starter month to the next month. Sometimes its hard to get shows when you are first starting....
 
You can't change the month now.
 
To get her orientated with her kit, or any recruit for that matter, my director had us fill out this questionairre. She doesnt do that anymore, now she has recruits, open their kit first, lol, and in the use and care guide, she has the recruit write down two important features about the items (for example, dishwasher safe, can be put in the microwave) and then she has them write an item or two it can be cross selled with.

It works out well.

Then she gives the recruit the PC pocket book with the catalog holder in the front as an incentive.

Just a thought!! She gives a deadline on this "assignment" also.
 
I have one of these. I don't think she meant to be a kitnapper, I just think she is really lazy and a bit dishonest. She did present ONE show in late July, which she split into 2 so she could get her piece of cookware. She hasn't done a thing since. I have talked to her, guided her, offered incentives, the whole bit. Finally I got tired of her excuses and told her Look- if you don't want to do this, I can't help you can I? She swore she did want to do it, so I told her I had given her all the ideas and words I had, and to give me a call when she had a show scheduled. I haven't heard from her since. It sort of sucks, but I can't really count on her (unless she pulls something out of a hat) so I am just on to find another recruit rather than worrying too too much about her.
 
The person that recruited me had another recruit that never did anything and was forgotten about until almost a year after being recruited, she got a notice that they had qualified and the pack of catalogues. I didn't realize they had that much time to qualify.
 
If she is going to fairs and one of your shows I don't think that she is a kit napper, they wouldn't put that much effort into getting free product would they?

Maybe she just needs a fire lit under her. I would sit down and talk to her and ask her what she wants out of her business and set in motion an action plan on achieving it.
 
All consultants have 12 months after they go inactive to submit $200 in commissionable sales to become active again. A recruit who didn't qualify would become active with the same $200 but she would need to also need to have reached a total of 4 shows or $1250 in sales to also qualify.

If a recruit goes inactive before qualifying the recruiter does not get the 2000 trip points or any other promotion that is going on at the time even if the person later qualifies.

When I first started I had someone go inactive for 1 month and then qualify and she lost her sales to that point and didn't get her trip points and I lost out on my trip points and at that time $50 PC$$ - my director hadn't told me to watch that with my recruit and she hadn't said anything to her either - I guess we were supposed to know it by osmosis. :grumpy:

ANYWAY! Now YOU know so keep it in mind. I ALWAYS remind my consultants when deadlines are coming so if they don't make it they can't come back to me and say they didn't know - I call and then follow up with an email reminder. They have said they really appreciate it and I know I would have!
 
  • Thread starter
  • #13
I do feel that she wanted to start and not be a kitnapper. I really need to find out again what her goal is and encourage her to have her own show or catalog show. It's hard when I have two more ladies ready to sign and I'm waiting for her to start her business.
I think I'm having a hard time because I'm a self starter and didn't need to much help to start.
I'll be calling her Weds to see if she has anything going on.
Thanks you all. You are great!!
 
Tell her she'll have to send her kit back if she doesn't hold up her end of the contract. I've heard many successful recruiters do this. Maybe that will spark something.
 
Paula R. Lewis said:
Are you sure she even has legitimate bookings? She should've had 4-6 bookings on her contract!

When I first started, my upline director asked for my bookings. She then sent a letter to each hostess herself, thanking them for helping me get started. After the show was held and submitted, she then sent each of them a Mini-serving spatula as a small thank you.

You may want to consider something similar, if it will help...?

Sorry, but she is starting to sound like a "kit-napper"!! I hope I'm wrong!

Best wishes,
Paula
Click to expand...

Oh Paula!!
What an awesome director !I love it!!
You wouldn't happen to have a copy of the letter she sends would you?
 
Paula R. Lewis said:
But the question remains...where are her first 4-6 hostesses? Shouldn't she have done their shows by now?

The dates for her first shows should have been in the first 30 days. If she is already past that time frame, what's going on?

If you think she's really going to do this, you may want to see if she is able to change her start date. We used to be able to move it ahead by one month, before the new Super Starter program came out. I don't know if it's still available now, though, since it's a new program. To do it in the past, she had to submit a written request to Field Services. It could even be done via email. Other than that, however, I don't know what to tell you, other than to be a little suspicious at this point, perhaps?

I've had the unfortunate experience of signing a few "kit-nappers"...or, as I prefer to call them...."liars and thieves"!! They are not pleasant to deal with, and it really irks me when it happens. (can you tell? lol)

I hope she isn't one of THEM.....:0)

Good luck to you!
Paula
Click to expand...

We can no longer move start dates under any circumstances.
And, PS, I am with you on the liars & thieves attitude.
 
What???
missyciccolella said:
Tell her she'll have to send her kit back if she doesn't hold up her end of the contract. I've heard many successful recruiters do this. Maybe that will spark something.
Click to expand...

That is a lie!! LOL
That wouldn't be good to threaten someone and then not be able to follow through. Unfortunately some people are kit nappers and don't intend to do anything more than get their products for a discount. We can't really know what a person's intentions are unless we know them personally. I would suggest you just keep trying to contact her and find out for sure if she means to ever have a show or not. I wouldn't waste my time on someone who is a kit napper. I'm sure she might not have meant to become a kit napper but if someone is not really motivated to do shows, not at all your fault since you have made many efforts to offer incentives and get her started, there is nothing we can do.

Debbie :D
 
I had the most bizarre kitnapper. She was a HO Lead. Signed after a 20 minute conversation on the phone. Came for a new consultant training and came again for a one on one traniing. About 3 days after signing, she registered for NC, booked flight and a hotel room with some of our clustermates. Then, the day before we were to fly out, she called and said she wasn't coming. Drove 1/2hr to my house to drop off $ to cover her space in the hotel room, never contacted HO to get her registration $ refunded and has not returned a call from me since. BIZARRE...
 
dannyzmom said:
I had the most bizarre kitnapper. She was a HO Lead. Signed after a 20 minute conversation on the phone. Came for a new consultant training and came again for a one on one traniing. About 3 days after signing, she registered for NC, booked flight and a hotel room with some of our clustermates. Then, the day before we were to fly out, she called and said she wasn't coming. Drove 1/2hr to my house to drop off $ to cover her space in the hotel room, never contacted HO to get her registration $ refunded and has not returned a call from me since. BIZARRE...
Click to expand...

She did all that and never turned in a show? That is BIZARRE! She actually invested alot of time and money to just drop off the face of then earth......hmmmmm, I hope that isn't what actually happened!
 
Some will, some won't, oh, well. Who's next?

It's a numbers game, folks! Directors I've spoken with, say about half of new recruits actually launch. I mistakenly recruited a go-getter with Mary Kay. She signed with me in May. She became a MK director and has a MK car as of July. Of course, as a director with another company, she signed a non-compete clause--she cannot represent another company. My bad. Right person, wrong timing.
 
BethCooks4U said:
All consultants have 12 months after they go inactive to submit $200 in commissionable sales to become active again. A recruit who didn't qualify would become active with the same $200 but she would need to also need to have reached a total of 4 shows or $1250 in sales to also qualify.

If a recruit goes inactive before qualifying the recruiter does not get the 2000 trip points or any other promotion that is going on at the time even if the person later qualifies.

When I first started I had someone go inactive for 1 month and then qualify and she lost her sales to that point and didn't get her trip points and I lost out on my trip points and at that time $50 PC$$ - my director hadn't told me to watch that with my recruit and she hadn't said anything to her either - I guess we were supposed to know it by osmosis. :grumpy:

ANYWAY! Now YOU know so keep it in mind. I ALWAYS remind my consultants when deadlines are coming so if they don't make it they can't come back to me and say they didn't know - I call and then follow up with an email reminder. They have said they really appreciate it and I know I would have!
Click to expand...

OH DRATS!! That stinks!
One of my recruits was doing good...her first show was $650, and she turned in another show to get the 2 sharp items in June...but she didn't do anything JUly or Aug...so she went inactive...turned in a small show ($160) in Sept...but her status is Inactive...and she never qualified! only 3 shows, and they don't add up to $1250! So I'll never get my 2000 points? AHHHH!!

My other recruit, only a couple small shows so far...hasn't qualified...
My question to all of you... How do you motivate them to not go inactive? For me it's a HUGE 2000 points...but they don't care about my points!
I know when I was new, I didn't care about loosing my career sales - at their point, they don't either.

I hear from them that they are busy, etc...I've given one of them a show and a fair booth I was asked to do...and the other one I gave a booking, I just don't know what else to do to motivate them...flyers to send them for ideas...

AND...I don't want them to think I am doing it for my own good...they both signed without hosting, and they both really want to do it, but they aren't concerned with doing a fantabulous job...it's more of a little something on the side for them...

:confused: :confused: :confused: :rolleyes:
 
Half of new recruits actually launch.

That is good information actually. It makes me feel better about those who fizzle. I haven't had half fizzle, but enough to make me feel icky about it.

friday
 
ChefNic said:
My question to all of you... How do you motivate them to not go inactive? For me it's a HUGE 2000 points...but they don't care about my points!
I know when I was new, I didn't care about loosing my career sales - at their point, they don't either.
Click to expand...
I hear you on that one - the last thing a new consultant is concerned about is their recruiter's goals (generally - there are exceptions). I've found that offering a small gift for qualifying within 90 days can be the "carrot" for them to qualify without going inactive (since they can't go inactive until their 90 days are done). I've offered a tote bag - it's not too expensive and is a useful item they can use to boost their business. You can offer a Merrill bag, or the catalog tote from supply order. Or something else that they seem interested in. :)
 
chefann said:
I hear you on that one - the last thing a new consultant is concerned about is their recruiter's goals (generally - there are exceptions). I've found that offering a small gift for qualifying within 90 days can be the "carrot" for them to qualify without going inactive (since they can't go inactive until their 90 days are done). I've offered a tote bag - it's not too expensive and is a useful item they can use to boost their business. You can offer a Merrill bag, or the catalog tote from supply order. Or something else that they seem interested in. :)
Click to expand...


I saw other people on other threads say about using the Catalog Tote as an incentive and I really like that idea. I love mine and I think that every consultant should have one.
 
Great idea!
I've given them little things after they signed...Red PC coozie cup from Merrill, key chain (old style from Nancy's Artwork, I had extras)
I'm gonna think about the gift when they qualify though!
THX
 
Nicole,
Don't forget to crunch numbers for her about what getting the extra 2% means to the pocketbook. Some consultants probably get discouraged because their per show sales are not that high. So, being reminded about how to maximize the commission, I think, helps. Also, I heard one of the HO sales managers say that the PT/hobbyists who only do one or two shows a month have lower per show averages than those who do 2 shows per week or more. Remind them that the more shows they do, the better they will get at increasing their sales because they'll be more comfortable doing their shows--and it'll come easier to them to do them and enjoy themselves. Just my humble .02!
 
ChefNic said:
OH DRATS!! That stinks!
One of my recruits was doing good...her first show was $650, and she turned in another show to get the 2 sharp items in June...but she didn't do anything JUly or Aug...so she went inactive...turned in a small show ($160) in Sept...but her status is Inactive...and she never qualified! only 3 shows, and they don't add up to $1250! So I'll never get my 2000 points? AHHHH!!

My other recruit, only a couple small shows so far...hasn't qualified...
My question to all of you... How do you motivate them to not go inactive? For me it's a HUGE 2000 points...but they don't care about my points!
I know when I was new, I didn't care about loosing my career sales - at their point, they don't either.

I hear from them that they are busy, etc...I've given one of them a show and a fair booth I was asked to do...and the other one I gave a booking, I just don't know what else to do to motivate them...flyers to send them for ideas...

AND...I don't want them to think I am doing it for my own good...they both signed without hosting, and they both really want to do it, but they aren't concerned with doing a fantabulous job...it's more of a little something on the side for them...

:confused: :confused: :confused: :rolleyes:
Click to expand...
It's not about you. It's all about them. They have to want it. No matter how much you want it for them (or yourself) they will not get inspired until they feel the fire. Why did they sign? What is their why? Find that out and you'll have something to help you help them.
 
As the wise PC sage Colleen told me a while back...you can't work harder on their business than they are willing to work themselves!
 
Thanks Lamar!
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I do if my new recruit is not showing enthusiasm for the business?

It's important to have open communication with your recruit. Schedule a one-on-one conversation to understand their concerns and motivations. Sometimes, a lack of enthusiasm can stem from feeling overwhelmed or unsure about the next steps. Offer support, resources, and encouragement to help reignite their passion for the business.

How can I motivate a recruit who seems disengaged?

Try to identify what initially attracted them to the business. Remind them of their goals and the potential benefits of being part of the team. You can also share success stories from other team members, provide incentives for achieving small milestones, or involve them in team activities to foster a sense of belonging and motivation.

Is it normal to feel frustrated with a new recruit's progress?

Yes, it's completely normal to feel frustrated when a recruit isn't progressing as expected. Remember that everyone has their own pace and challenges. It's essential to remain patient and supportive, as your encouragement can make a significant difference in their journey.

When should I consider letting go of a recruit?

If you've provided ample support and encouragement but see no improvement or willingness to engage, it may be time to reassess the situation. Consider having a candid conversation about their commitment to the business. If they express disinterest, it might be best to part ways amicably, allowing both of you to focus on more motivated individuals.

How can I prevent feeling like my efforts are wasted with new recruits?

Focus on setting realistic expectations and celebrating small wins, both for yourself and your recruits. Remember that not every recruit will thrive, but your efforts contribute to the overall growth of your team. Keep a positive mindset, seek support from fellow leaders, and remind yourself of the successes you've achieved with others.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Venting Frustrations: My Recruiting Session Woes
  • ChefBevShu
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
8
Views
2K
cookingwithlove
Director Why is my new consultant not receiving her fall changeover box?
  • finley1991
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
4
Views
1K
tpchefpattie
Director Learn from My Mistakes: The Importance of Timely Submission in Direct Sales
  • PCJenni
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
2
Views
977
finley1991
Awaiting a Response: Working with a Potential Recruit with Family Issues
  • babywings76
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
9
Views
2K
EmilyStraw
Helping a New Recruit: Challenges of a Consultant
  • missmindym
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
7
Views
2K
cookingwithlove
Director Warning...long Vent,Rant, Whining and Complaining
  • baychef
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
18
Views
2K
Sheila
Duped by a Kitnapper: My Tale of Frustration
  • peichef
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
6
Views
2K
TammyStar
Motivating My First Recruit: Tips for Encouraging Success in Direct Sales
  • melaniepc
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
11
Views
2K
Jenni
Rant Frustrated New TL: Struggling to Help My Team Reach Success
  • kayleigh
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
17
Views
2K
Sheila
Is It Possible to Become a Future Director with Only One Active Recruit?
  • ChefinHarmony
    • Recruiting and Team Leaders
Replies
3
Views
2K
cmdtrgd
Back
Top