Are New Knives with Honing Tools Better Than Self-Sharpening Ones?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The thread explores opinions on the new knives with honing tools compared to self-sharpening knives and forged cutlery. Participants share their experiences and preferences regarding the design, usability, and performance of the new knives.

Discussion Character

  • Opinion-based
  • Anecdotal

Main Points Raised

  • One participant, identifying as a consultant, expresses love for their forged cutlery but is curious about the new knives with honing tools.
  • Another participant shares their experience with the paring knife, noting its impressive performance and better handle feel compared to older models, though they remain loyal to forged cutlery.
  • Several users mention that the new knives have a modern appearance and are suitable for those on a budget, though not seen as investment knives.
  • One participant appreciates the locking mechanism of the honing tool, highlighting its user-friendliness compared to older sharpening methods.
  • Another participant notes that the new knives feel light, with one finding them too light for their preference.
  • One participant mentions that they plan to purchase specific new knives due to customer interest, while also noting the shorter guarantee period compared to forged cutlery.
  • Another participant states a preference for forged cutlery over self-sharpening knives, citing the new knives' lightness and the change in guarantee as positive aspects for forged cutlery.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ on the overall preference between the new knives and forged cutlery, with some participants expressing satisfaction with the new knives while others remain loyal to forged cutlery. No clear consensus emerges regarding which option is superior.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences and preferences, reflecting a variety of opinions on knife usability and design without implying any official guidance or recommendations.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants interested in understanding customer perspectives on the new knives and those comparing them to forged cutlery and self-sharpening options may find this discussion relevant.

itsjustCarla
itsjustCarla
Messages
648
Just curious.....I LOVE my forged cutlery, but was curious as to what everyone thinks about the new knives with the honing tool???
 
I decided to get the paring knife...so I would have one to show if needed, and so I would know how they work. I am honestly impressed with it so far. I don't use my other sharpening knives/cases anymore since I am in love with my forged cutlery...but I think it cuts pretty nice, and the feel of the handle in my hand is MUCH BETTER than our old ones.

It's not going to make me switch over, but I DO like them!
 
I like them. They're more modern looking than the old versions. Still not an investment knife, but good for people on a budget.
 
chefann said:
I like them. They're more modern looking than the old versions. Still not an investment knife, but good for people on a budget.
Click to expand...

And good to take along if you'll need a knife at a picnic or other such event.
 
BethCooks4U said:
And good to take along if you'll need a knife at a picnic or other such event.
Click to expand...

I agree! I like the "locking" mechanism so they can't fall out of the honer tool.

I also like that they are much more user friendly than the old ones. Unless someone got a personal visual lesson on how to use the old sharpener cases, it seemed like I was getting complaints that their knives weren't sharpening. Once I would see how they used the sharpening case, normally I would notice that they weren't engaging the mechanism at all...or that they weren't sharpening the entire length of the blade. Hopefully, these will be easier for the masses to use properly!! lol
 
itsjustCarla said:
Just curious.....I LOVE my forged cutlery, but was curious as to what everyone thinks about the new knives with the honing tool???
Click to expand...

I never used the old ones, so I don't have a basis of comparison except to the Forged Cutlery. I have the paring knife and it just feels so light in my hand! Too light for me, actually.
 
I love the forged knifes I know some of my hostess are doing shows just to get that whole set as an 1/2 price item and to people who aren't wanting the whole set is excited to see that the bamboo knife block is seperate.

I haven't gotten one neg. thought about the set at all or even the price of it. They find it is very appealing for all they are getting in the set. I have a host who is going to work on getting it as an 1/2 priced item and try to get another 1/2 price for the steak knifes. So I think it will go really well all the way around. People have been asking if they had a knife block and then they always say i wish we could get the knifes in a set without having a party.
 
KellyTheChef said:
I agree! I like the "locking" mechanism so they can't fall out of the honer tool.

I also like that they are much more user friendly than the old ones. Unless someone got a personal visual lesson on how to use the old sharpener cases, it seemed like I was getting complaints that their knives weren't sharpening. Once I would see how they used the sharpening case, normally I would notice that they weren't engaging the mechanism at all...or that they weren't sharpening the entire length of the blade. Hopefully, these will be easier for the masses to use properly!! lol
Click to expand...

I've encountered the "need a lesson" issue with several consultants who were playing with the new knives. It showed me that a) the icons in the case aren't obvious enough nor as intuitive as they should be; and b) many consultants haven't watched the DVD that shows how to use them (this one really bugs me - how are they supposed to sell the new items if they don't know anything about them?)
 
I don't have the new ones yet, but plan on getting the 5" and pairing knife since these are the ones I get asked to look at the most.

I did see them at my cluster meeting and thought they were nice. The only thing to remember is the guarantee is now 5 years and not lifetime like the old ones. I think this will be a better selling point for the forged. I will certainly encourage the forged over them due to the guarantee:)! Plus I like them much better.
 
I know this is one of those products I'll need to demonstrate at each show. I know my customers can read; it's just that so many of them don't.
 
I think in comparison to the self-sharpening knives the new ones win hands down. I earned the 3" paring knife in SAT and I can honestly say I will not be ordering another one of them. I only use my FC and I will be putting the self-sharpening knives in my camper as they will be fine there, but I do not use them in my kitchen. I agree the new ones feel light, too light in my hands.
I also love the change in the guarantee!!!! I think this is a GREAT thing for FC!!!
 

Frequently Asked Questions

Are new knives with honing tools better than self-sharpening ones?

It depends on personal preference and usage. Knives with honing tools require regular maintenance to keep them sharp, while self-sharpening knives are designed to sharpen themselves with each use. If you prefer a hands-on approach and enjoy honing your knives, traditional knives with honing tools might be better for you. However, if convenience is a priority, self-sharpening knives may be the way to go.

How often do I need to hone my knives?

It is recommended to hone your knives before each use, especially if you use them frequently. Honing realigns the blade's edge and helps maintain sharpness. With regular honing, your knives can stay sharp longer, reducing the need for more extensive sharpening.

Can self-sharpening knives be as sharp as traditional knives?

Self-sharpening knives can achieve a good level of sharpness, but they may not reach the same level as well-maintained traditional knives. The sharpening mechanism in self-sharpening knives is designed for convenience, which may not provide the same precision as manual sharpening techniques.

Are honing tools easy to use for beginners?

Yes, honing tools are generally easy to use, even for beginners. Most honing rods come with instructions, and with a little practice, you can quickly learn the proper technique to maintain your knife's edge. Watching tutorial videos can also help you get the hang of it.

What is the lifespan of self-sharpening knives compared to traditional knives?

The lifespan of both types of knives can vary based on usage and care. Self-sharpening knives may have a longer lifespan if used correctly, as they maintain their edge with each use. Traditional knives can last a lifetime if properly maintained and sharpened regularly. Ultimately, the longevity of either type depends on the quality of the materials and how well they are cared for.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

"Self Honing Knife" With No Case
  • Intrepid_Chef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
Admin Greg
Forged Cutlery Collection Vs. Self-Honing Knives
  • dkitten13
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
4K
babywings76
Can Honing Tools Be Used with Non-PC Knives?
  • AmaraJ
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
1K
Admin Greg
Understanding the Honing Tool: Usage and Compatibility
  • Pampered Laura
    • Products and Tips
Replies
9
Views
2K
lacychef
Can the Honing Tool Help Other Knives Besides Forged Cutlery?
  • sillylittlechef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
sillylittlechef
Use of Honing Tool w/ Other Knives - Warning!
  • Kathytnt
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
jenniferknapp
How do you properly use a Forged Cutlery Honing Tool for kitchen knives?
  • sjspchef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
Admin Greg
The Difference in Price Between Knives on Pages 31 and 32
  • Kenzie09
    • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
2K
AmyDare
Can the Honing Tool Be Used on Knives Other Than Pampered Chef?
  • babywings76
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
1K
babywings76
Confused About the Bamboo Knife Block and New Knives - Help Please
  • kcjodih
    • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
2K
Staci
Back
Top