An Important Question: Steel or Aluminum Sheet Pans?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread centers around a question regarding the material composition of sheet pans and cookie sheets, specifically whether they are made of steel or aluminum. Participants share their personal experiences with the products, particularly focusing on issues related to warping during use.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses uncertainty about the materials of the sheet pans and seeks clarification.
  • Another participant believes the sheet pans are aluminum on the inside for heat conduction and steel on the outside.
  • A participant cites information from a source indicating that the sheet pans are made of 0.8mm aluminized steel, designed for even heat distribution and durability.
  • Several participants share experiences regarding warping, noting that their cookie sheets have twisted in the oven, while they have not experienced this with the sheet pans.
  • One participant mentions that their cookie sheet twisted during use but returned to shape, suggesting it may be a first-time occurrence.
  • Another participant points out that the cookie sheet is noticeably thinner than the sheet pans, which may contribute to the warping issue.
  • One participant shares a specific experience of their cookie sheet twisting after multiple uses, expressing disappointment but still liking the product overall.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ regarding the warping of cookie sheets versus sheet pans, with some participants noting that cookie sheets may warp while sheet pans do not. No clear consensus emerges on the overall performance of the products.

Contextual Notes

Participants discuss their personal experiences with the products, focusing on the performance of sheet pans and cookie sheets in relation to warping and material composition.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants interested in understanding the material properties and performance of Pampered Chef sheet pans and cookie sheets may find this discussion relevant.

C
Crystal Patton
Messages
962
I have a Host who is ... (I can't think of a nice word right now). She wants to know if the sheet pans are steel on the inside, aluminum on the outside or the other way around. It doesn't say in the catty and I have learned NOT to assume anything with her.

Does anyone know?

Thanks!
 
I think they are Aluminum on the inside (for heat conduction), and then Steel on the outside. I'll see if I can find the info where I saw that.
 
Here you go....from the "PIG" on CC.
Features & Benefits:
The Sheet Pans are constructed of 0.8mm aluminized steel and are perfect for baking,
roasting and broiling. Rolled edges are reinforced with a wire rim to add durability and prevent warping even
when used in the broiler. 1"/2.5 cm high sides provide an easy grip and prevent juices and batters from spilling
over. Uncoated aluminized steel provides even heat distribution, so cookies and rolls won't have burnt bottoms.
Easy-release properties provide effortless cleanup in the dishwasher. Pans nest for easy storage.
Click to expand...
 
Just a note about the "warping" or twisting....I've never had my sheet-pans do "the oven-twist", but my new Cookie Sheet did when I first used it. It popped back though and didn't stay that way (like some kinds do).....just twisted a bit in the oven. So be sure if you tell customers that our pans won't warp or twist- you are specifying the SHEET PANS. :)
 
  • Thread starter
  • #5
Thanks guys!!!
 
esavvymom said:
Just a note about the "warping" or twisting....I've never had my sheet-pans do "the oven-twist", but my new Cookie Sheet did when I first used it. It popped back though and didn't stay that way (like some kinds do).....just twisted a bit in the oven. So be sure if you tell customers that our pans won't warp or twist- you are specifying the SHEET PANS. :)
Click to expand...

I had the same thing happen but didn't post on it. The cookie sheet will twist and pop back. The sheet pans do not. Structurally it makes sense...
 
esavvymom said:
Just a note about the "warping" or twisting....I've never had my sheet-pans do "the oven-twist", but my new Cookie Sheet did when I first used it. It popped back though and didn't stay that way (like some kinds do).....just twisted a bit in the oven. So be sure if you tell customers that our pans won't warp or twist- you are specifying the SHEET PANS. :)
Click to expand...

I noticed this the first time with my cookie sheet too and I was very bummed. But i have to say that in subsequent uses I have NOT noticed that happening. So I'm hopeful that it's just a "first time use" phenomenon.
 
They are noticeably thinner than the sheet pans. I just pointed it out so we didn't mistakenly say that all of the sheet pans/cookie sheet would not twist. It's good to know they may only do it the first time though. I've only used it once so far myself. I'll watch and see what happens the next time.
 
I used my cookie sheet to make Spritz Cookies last night and after the 3rd or so batch it made the distictive popping sound and sure enough, it had twisted! This wasn't the first time I had used the sheet either, I was very surprised and a little disappointed as well. I do still love the cookie sheet even though it pops.
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between steel and aluminum sheet pans?

Steel sheet pans are typically heavier and provide better heat retention, which can lead to more even baking. Aluminum sheet pans are lighter, heat up quickly, and are less likely to warp. Both materials have their advantages depending on the cooking method and desired results.

Which material is better for baking cookies?

Aluminum sheet pans are often preferred for baking cookies because they heat up quickly and promote even browning. However, if you prefer a crispier bottom, a steel sheet pan may be a better choice due to its heat retention properties.

Are there any health concerns with using aluminum sheet pans?

There are some discussions about aluminum leaching into food, especially when cooking acidic foods. However, most studies suggest that the amount is minimal and generally safe for most people. If you have concerns, consider using coated aluminum pans or opting for stainless steel alternatives.

Can I use steel sheet pans for roasting vegetables?

Yes, steel sheet pans are excellent for roasting vegetables as they can withstand high temperatures and provide a nice caramelization due to their heat retention. Just be sure to monitor cooking times to avoid burning.

How do I care for my steel and aluminum sheet pans?

For both steel and aluminum sheet pans, it's best to hand wash them with mild soap and avoid using abrasive cleaners that can scratch the surface. Steel pans may require seasoning to prevent rust, while aluminum pans should be dried immediately to prevent discoloration.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

What Chemicals are in Our Stainless Steel Pans?
  • Cooking_Mama
    • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
2K
DebbieJ
Aluminum in Food: Guest's Concerns & My Response
  • wadesgirl
    • Products and Tips
Replies
9
Views
2K
Kathy's_Kitchen
Sheet Pans: Replacement Wait Update
  • wadesgirl
    • Products and Tips
Replies
10
Views
2K
MissChef
Is the Bottom of the Digital Pocket Thermometer Stainless or Aluminum?
  • ChefLAM
    • Products and Tips
Replies
9
Views
5K
Zsu
Becky Seeks Help with Buckling Sheet Pans
  • jbdowd0798
    • Products and Tips
Replies
5
Views
6K
mrshamel3808
Cleaning Sticky Sheet Pans: Solutions & FAQs
  • Mel92504
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
3K
pampchefrhondab
Stop Sell on Sheet Pans Question...
  • KellyTheChef
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
wadesgirl
Product Suggestions and Tips From Test Kitchen!
  • heat123
    • Products and Tips
Replies
15
Views
4K
heat123
Any Update on When We Can Sell Sheet Pans?
  • SusanPC
    • Products and Tips
Replies
5
Views
1K
GeorgiaPeach
Sheet Pans Washing Woes - Don't Let It Happen To You!
  • merego
    • Products and Tips
Replies
8
Views
2K
lacychef
Back
Top