How Do You Use an Ice Cream Sandwich Maker?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This thread explores various experiences and opinions regarding the use of an ice cream sandwich maker. Participants share their personal insights on its functionality, ease of use, and alternative methods for making ice cream sandwiches.

Discussion Character

  • Anecdotal
  • Opinion-based
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant, identifying as a consultant, hosted an ice cream party and felt unsure about using the ice cream sandwich maker properly.
  • Another participant expressed a negative opinion, stating that the ice cream sandwich maker is "worthless" and prefers making sandwiches by hand.
  • Several users mentioned using store-bought cookies, such as Pepperidge Farm and Meijer-brand cookies, as suitable options for the sandwich maker.
  • One participant shared a detailed method for using the sandwich maker, emphasizing the importance of soft ice cream and the technique for pressing the cookies together.
  • Another participant noted that their child enjoys the ice cream sandwich maker, suggesting it may be more appealing for families with young children.
  • One participant mentioned giving away their ice cream sandwich maker due to confusion over the instructions.
  • Another participant highlighted using the sandwich maker for making brownie ice cream sandwiches as an alternative approach.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Views differ significantly among participants, with some expressing frustration and others sharing positive experiences. No clear consensus emerges regarding the effectiveness of the ice cream sandwich maker.

Contextual Notes

Participants share personal experiences and preferences, reflecting a variety of approaches to making ice cream sandwiches, including both the use of the sandwich maker and alternative methods.

Who May Find This Useful

Consultants and community members interested in diverse experiences with the ice cream sandwich maker may find this discussion valuable.

Joelen
Joelen
Messages
120
I hosted an ice cream party over the weekend and used the ice cream sandwich maker. I felt so silly looking at the picture in the catalog and reading through the instructions, but I don't think we really were using it properly. Can someone please "dumb down" the use of this product?!?
 
Ummm, yeah.......the ice cream sandwich maker. IMHO - it's worthless! It's easier and faster to make ice cream sandwiches by hand. Use the large SS scoop to bake your cookies - making sure that the scoop is filled and leveled off to the top for each cookie. Bake the cookies, and once cooled, put a scoop of ice cream on one, press the other cookie on top of it, and roll in assorted toppings.:D
 
I have a pdf of the instructions. Email me.

Or, it might even still be behind CC. You could search and find out.

edited to add---ooh, look! I can actually attach it here!
 

Attachments

Last edited:
ChefBeckyD said:
Ummm, yeah.......the ice cream sandwich maker. IMHO - it's worthless! It's easier and faster to make ice cream sandwiches by hand. Use the large SS scoop to bake your cookies - making sure that the scoop is filled and leveled off to the top for each cookie. Bake the cookies, and once cooled, put a scoop of ice cream on one, press the other cookie on top of it, and roll in assorted toppings.:D
Click to expand...

This is so true! I hate this product! I think it is easier to use if you think of it more as a "guide" to keep things stacked neatly than a "tool" which would be doing something.

Also, soft Pepperidge Farm cookies (the big ones) fit in just right and will keep you from having to make your own homemade cookies.
 
Archway cookies are just the right size, too. As are the Meijer-brand version. I love the Meijer molasses cookies with coffee ice cream. mmm.....
 
chefann said:
I love the Meijer molasses cookies with coffee ice cream. mmm.....
Click to expand...

Ooh...that sounds good!
 
I actually sell a lot of the ice cream sandwich makers and I find it makes them perfectly...but the catalog picture doesn't show to use it well (AT ALL).

You basically do reverse of the picture; put cookie in, then 2 scoops of ice cream (that is a bit softened) and then another cookie on top. Then to actually MAKE the sandwich....you turn it over so last cookie is now on a cutting board/surface. Press the gray plunger like thing down, firm but not to firm, until you see the ice cream squeeze between the two cookies. This spreads the ice cream out well, makes an even ice cream sandwich, and allows for easy rolling in other things like crushed nuts, sprinkles, etc.

In my area, store bought Franz brand cookies work best.

I sell these by suggesting that a) you can control what goes in your ice cream sandwich (so can use frozen yogurt, low fat cookies, etc); and b) you can make a lot ahead of time and freeze individualy, and c) great activity to do with kids.
 
  • Thread starter
  • #8
Pics of the event I hosted are on my blog. We used Sams Club cookies which were perfectly soft to work with and used both the ice cream sandwich maker and dipper. Everyone loved the dipper but 2 gals got the sandwich maker and left puzzled. I also told those 2 that they could use it for forming hamburger patties and individual meatloaf rounds. {sigh... hope they enjoy it!}

Overall it was a great event - lots of cookies and ice creams/frozen yogurts!
 
Sounds like you had a good time.
 
I gave mine away because I had know idea how to use it! The instructions don't help at all!
 
We only use ours because our 4 yr. old thinks it's the best thing ever! Once the kids are grown - it's out...
 
Am I the only one that thinks April looks like LeAnn Rimes? Beautiful!
 
KellyTheChef said:
Am I the only one that thinks April looks like LeAnn Rimes? Beautiful!
Click to expand...

THAT'S who it is! I kept thinking she looked like someone!
 
She does look like LeAnn Rimes!!
 
KellyTheChef said:
Am I the only one that thinks April looks like LeAnn Rimes? Beautiful!
Click to expand...

THAT'S who she reminds me of!! Thanks, Kelly!! LOL! You're right! ;)

Oh, and back on topic - the ice cream sandwich maker - I've sold a bunch of them when I demo them at summer shows. I use the cookies from the grocery store bakery (they're always a bit bigger than the pre-packaged) and bring them myself, then tell the host to supply her favorite ice cream and sprinkles/nuts. I do it how it was described (1 cookie, 2 scoops of soft ice cream, 1 more cookie, MUSH), then roll it in the sprinkles or nuts. I then cut them in half and let everyone take a piece (displayed beautifully on my Simple Additions, of course!). I've sold a ton of them this way, but they even sell without me even bringing them to shows, so I guess people like them around here. Hey, it's Philly, the fattest city in the country - of course we like our ice cream cookie sandwiches!! LOL! ;)
 
My DH wants the ice cream sandwich maker... I think my DH is worse then me when it comes to spending money on PC!!
 
You can also bake 2 boxes of brownie mix in the Lg Stoneware bar pan, then cut your brownines into circles (using the ic sand. maker) while they are warm from the oven. Remove frome the pan, cool then use those perfect little circles of chocolate to make brownie ice cream sandwiches.
Deb
 

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you use an ice cream sandwich maker?

To use an ice cream sandwich maker, start by preparing your cookie dough according to your recipe. Preheat the ice cream sandwich maker if required. Once ready, place a small amount of dough into each compartment of the maker, close the lid, and cook for the recommended time. After baking, allow the cookies to cool before adding your favorite ice cream in between two cookies to create your sandwich.

Can I use store-bought cookie dough in an ice cream sandwich maker?

Yes, you can use store-bought cookie dough in an ice cream sandwich maker. Just scoop the dough into the compartments of the maker as you would with homemade dough, and follow the manufacturer's instructions for cooking time.

What types of cookies work best in an ice cream sandwich maker?

Soft and chewy cookies work best in an ice cream sandwich maker. Varieties like chocolate chip, sugar cookies, or peanut butter cookies are ideal as they hold their shape well and complement the ice cream texture.

How long does it take to make cookies in an ice cream sandwich maker?

The cooking time for cookies in an ice cream sandwich maker typically ranges from 5 to 10 minutes, depending on the specific model and the thickness of the cookie dough. Always refer to the manufacturer's instructions for the best results.

Can I make mini ice cream sandwiches with an ice cream sandwich maker?

Yes, you can make mini ice cream sandwiches using an ice cream sandwich maker by using smaller amounts of cookie dough. Adjust the amount of dough you place in each compartment to create smaller cookies that can be paired with a smaller scoop of ice cream.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar Pampered Chef Threads

Ice Cream Maker & Ice Cream Scoop
  • ChefRiGuy
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
4K
Admin Greg
Transporting the Ice Cream Maker
  • mspibb
    • Products and Tips
Replies
4
Views
6K
Staci
Ice Cream Sandwich Maker Tips: How to Use and Troubleshoot
  • stefani2
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
Admin Greg
Other Uses for Ice Cream Sandwich Maker
  • Chef-B
    • Products and Tips
Replies
5
Views
3K
stacywhitlow
Use and Care for Old Ice Cream Sandwich Maker
  • Dea Rash
    • Business, Marketing and Customer Service
Replies
2
Views
5K
Admin Greg
Ice Cream Sandwich Maker Ideas: A Fun Guide for Gift Giving!
  • soccermama
    • Products and Tips
Replies
7
Views
2K
rlombas
Ice Cream Party Ideas: Delicious Tips for a Sweet Sunday Gathering
  • kcmckay
    • Recipes and Tips
Replies
2
Views
7K
Admin Greg
Make Delicious Ice Cream Sandwiches with the Sandwich Maker - Quick Tip Inside!
  • DebbieSM
    • Products and Tips
Replies
2
Views
2K
Windy City Pampered Chef
I Need an Ice Cream Sandwich Maker
  • dlsmeal
    • Buy Pampered Chef Items
Replies
4
Views
2K
pcsharon1
How Can You Make Personalized Ice Cream Cakes in Prep Bowls?
  • dannyzmom
    • Products and Tips
Replies
16
Views
3K
abaker1
Back
Top