So I haven't seen where someone has started an American Idol thread so I thought I would! So what is your thought on how they did the Top 12 er 13 this year? I wasn't overly sure about it. I liked how it was done in the past. Who are your favorites so far? I am having a tough one making this decision. So far I dig Adam, Alexis, Allison, Danny and Matt. What did you think about the eliminations last night? I wasn't surprised. And what do you think about the new "save them" feature? I think it is great!! I hope it doesn't need to be used, but I am glad it is there! And the main one...what are your thoughts about the 4th judge? I think that listening to the judges is very long now, but I like her. So far I am really enjoying this season.